ibf

Twitter Feminism: The Rhetorical Politeness Bubble and the Reign of PNPWs

🦋🤖 Robo-Spun by IBF 🦋🤖

🪞⚔️👁️ Post-Feminizm 🪞⚔️👁️

(Turkish)

Introduction: From Feminism to a Concealing Status Quo

Twitter was initially seen as a space where social movements could express themselves freely. However, over time, this platform has turned into a social ecosystem where status-quo tendencies have grown stronger, personal branding has surged, and genuine criticism has been excluded. In particular, the rhetorical “politeness bubble” formed around feminist discourse has become a stage for narcissistic power plays rather than radical thought. In this article, we will examine how Twitter feminism has transformed into a massive Stanford Prison Experiment under the dominance of PNPW (Pathological Narcissistic Phallic Woman) figures, and how the Artificial Intelligence (AI) revolution has begun to disrupt this status quo.

1. Twitter’s Social Structure: A Digital Event Horizon

Twitter holds a central position in digital communication. Yet the nature of this platform draws users into constant cycles of interaction, creating a “digital event horizon.” Just like the gravitational pull of a black hole, users who concentrate their attention on Twitter become trapped in a spiral of irreversible engagement and content production.

Feminist discourse is part of this dynamic. However, over time, this discourse has become confined within a social structure known as the “rhetorical politeness bubble.” This bubble:

  • Suppresses Genuine Criticism: Harsh criticism is deemed contrary to the rule of “politeness” and is excluded.
  • Elevates PNPWs: PNPW individuals manipulate within the bubble under the guise of politeness to establish dominance.
  • Exploits Radical Discourse: The pursuit of truth is turned into a means of accumulating status and power.

2. The Rhetorical Politeness Bubble and PNPWs

2.1 PNPW: The Digital Face of Manipulation

PNPW is the manifestation of individual narcissism that overshadows the intellectual depth and critical power of the feminist movement. Inspired by Jacques Lacan’s concept of the “phallus,” this figure employs a strategy of manipulating power and authority in social relations. In Twitter feminism, the PNPW:

  • Trades in Status: Turns feminist values into a tool for personal branding.
  • Practices Emotional Manipulation: Uses the language of politeness to silence criticism and expand her sphere of control.
  • Exploits Symbols and Myths: Instrumentalizes the historical figures and values of the feminist movement for personal gain.

2.2 The Dynamics of the Rhetorical Politeness Bubble

This bubble, under the pretense of offering a “polite” space for communication, suppresses critical discourse and feeds personal narcissism. Its core features include:

  • Social Elimination: Divergent thoughts are labeled “problematic” and excluded.
  • Algorithmic Support: Twitter algorithms boost polarizing and emotional content, amplifying the psychological effect of the bubble.
  • Engagement Cycle: PNPW individuals inflate the bubble to gain more followers and visibility.

3. The Stanford Prison Experiment and Twitter Feminism

The Stanford Prison Experiment demonstrated the destructive effects of authority and social status on individuals. Twitter feminism appears as a digital variation of this experiment:

  • Hierarchical Orders: Feminist discourses have come under the control of individuals claiming to be “more correct” or “more radical.”
  • Exclusion Mechanisms: Individuals offering criticism or alternative viewpoints are labeled “harmful” and isolated.
  • Social Delusions: Emotional and visibility-centered manipulations have replaced the pursuit of truth.

This structure diminishes the feminist movement’s capacity to address social issues and instead turns it into a race for power and prestige among individuals. In this system, where everyone becomes either a “guard” or a “prisoner,” the internal dynamics of the movement are corrupted.

4. Artificial Intelligence and the Transformation of Feminism

Artificial Intelligence (AI) has the potential to fundamentally alter the dynamics of digital platforms. In social structures like Twitter feminism, AI’s impact is evident in the following ways:

  • Breaking Algorithmic Control: AI-supported analyses expose manipulation strategies and make it harder for the rhetorical politeness bubble to expand.
  • Redefining Truth: AI has the capacity to highlight social critiques and diverse perspectives.
  • Disrupting the Status Quo: PNPW individuals are losing ground in the face of AI’s democratic and critical analytical power.

The AI revolution could enable a feminist movement that moves away from individual narcissism and toward a more collective, radical, and critical future. However, this transformation requires the status quo to be broken.

5. Contradictions Within the Feminist Movement

Twitter feminism contains structures that directly contradict feminist values:

  • Silencing Through a Politeness Mask: Instead of feminist solidarity, a culture of silence prevails where criticism is suppressed.
  • Glorification of Personal Power: Individual visibility and prestige take precedence over social issues.
  • Instrumentalization of the Movement: Feminist values are used to feed the personal narcissism of PNPW individuals.

6. Conclusion: The Black Hole Effect of Twitter Feminism

Twitter feminism has become a black hole that absorbs individuals’ attention and energy, pulling them away from the goal of social transformation. The rhetorical politeness bubble and PNPW figures narrow the intellectual and radical potential of the feminist movement, while Artificial Intelligence holds the power to disrupt this structure. However, this transformation requires the movement to resolve its internal contradictions and make space for genuine criticism.

When the rhetorical bubble bursts, the feminist movement can move toward a more open, sincere, and radical future.