🦋🤖 Robo-Spun by IBF 🦋🤖

🧵⚙️💪🏻 TEZGÂH 🧵⚙️💪🏻

Mirabilis jalapa thrives as a beloved ornamental known as the “four o’clock flower” or “marvel of Peru.” Native to tropical dry forests of the Americas (from Mexico and Guatemala down through Peru and Chile), it was cultivated by the Aztecs for its medicinal and decorative value and reached Europe by the 16th century[1]. Today it is naturalized across warm regions worldwide, admired for its remarkable floral variation. A single bushy M. jalapa plant, grown from one tuberous root, can simultaneously bear flowers of different colors and patterns. For example, one plant may bloom abundant pale yellow or white flowers, a smaller number of solid magenta or red flowers, and the rarest of all – a few light-colored blossoms splashed or spotted with darker pigment[2]. In horticultural terms these multi-hued blooms are variegated or “mosaic” flowers, displaying sectors, stripes (“flakes”), or speckles of contrasting color on the same flower. Often, entirely different colored flowers (plain yellow, pink, red, white, etc.) occur on different branches of the same plant[2]. This astonishing color mosaic trait has enchanted gardeners and botanists for centuries – indeed, it inspired the species name Mirabilis (“wonderful”) for its “admirable” colors[3]. The flowers open in late afternoon (around four o’clock) and release a sweet fragrance at night, attracting sphinx moths and other pollinators[4]. Culturally, the “marvel of Peru” earned a place in folk medicine and even as a source of natural dyes (the red flowers yield an edible crimson dye)[5][6]. Throughout history, people have been delighted by M. jalapa’s vibrant diversity – and perhaps a bit mystified: How can one plant produce so many different-looking flowers?

Understanding this mystery is not just a botanical curiosity; it also touches on how we humans interact with plant diversity. Imagine a gardener stumbling upon a particularly stunning Mirabilis bloom – say a pale yellow flower exquisitely peppered with maroon spots. The natural impulse might be to collect seeds from that one extraordinary flower, hoping to grow equally beautiful offspring. But here we pause and frame the central question of this report: Could our instinct to pick and propagate only the most beautifully patterned flowers inadvertently reduce variation in the long run? In other words, if we continually favor seeds from the rarest pattern, might we be bottlenecking the genetic and developmental diversity that makes M. jalapa so magical? This question will guide our exploration. We will delve into how variation arises in Mirabilis jalapa, from the level of a single seed and root to an entire population, and how human choices (like selective seed saving or pollination) might influence that variation. First, we’ll consider some general questions about how variation is generated and preserved, then explain – in both simple and scientific terms – the mechanisms behind those light, dark, and spotted flowers all coming from one plant. After that, we’ll walk through the plant’s natural life cycle to see when and where diversity comes into play or gets lost. Finally, we’ll suggest some gentle, hands-on strategies for gardeners to preserve and even enhance variation in their four o’clock flowers, so we can enjoy their full palette of surprises for generations to come.

General Questions About Variation in Seeds and Pollination

Before diving into technical explanations, let’s step back and ask a few broad questions about how variation works in M. jalapa (and plants in general). These will set the stage for understanding the specifics later on:

• Does a single seed limit or preserve variation? Each Mirabilis jalapa plant typically grows from one seed, which in turn came from one fertilized egg cell (zygote). That means an entire plant – all its roots, stems, leaves, and flowers – is initially the product of a single genetic individual. So, how can one such individual plant show so much internal variety (light, dark, and speckled flowers)? How important is the developmental process of a plant in generating new variation? For instance, as that single seed grows into a branching plant, could random changes or differences in different branches produce new colors that weren’t originally “in the seed”? We’ll explore whether the developmental journey from seed to flowering bush allows novel color patterns to appear, essentially within the lifetime of one plant. In short: to what extent can one seed yield many outcomes?
• What role does pollination play in maintaining diversity? Mirabilis jalapa flowers have both pollen and ovules (they are bisexual) and are known to self-pollinate readily[7]. However, their evening fragrance and nectar also attract moths, butterflies, and even hummingbirds, which can carry pollen from flower to flower[4][8]. Sometimes an insect might transfer pollen between two flowers on the same plant (a process called geitonogamy, which is essentially self-pollination by a pollinator), and other times it may visit another plant and bring in cross-pollination (also called allogamy, pollen from a different individual)[9]. We ask: How does pollination within the same plant versus between different plants affect variation? If a flower is pollinated by its neighbor on the same plant, the seed will carry genes only from that one plant – potentially limiting genetic diversity in the offspring. Conversely, if pollen comes from a completely different plant (perhaps one with different flower colors), the seed will contain a new combination of genes from two parents, possibly increasing variation in the next generation. So, is cross-pollination critical for maintaining the kaleidoscope of colors we see in M. jalapa populations? And if gardeners intervene – say, deliberately pollinating a spotted flower with pollen from a solid-colored flower – how might that influence the patterns in the resulting seeds? We will keep these questions in mind: they highlight the importance of both a plant’s developmental biology (from seed to flower) and its mode of pollination in the story of floral diversity.

With these general questions framed, we can now proceed to explain how one Mirabilis jalapa plant (one root system from one seed) can end up blooming in light colors, dark colors, and beautiful spotted mixes. We’ll first explain the mechanisms in simple, accessible terms, focusing on what happens during one plant’s growth and then how pollination comes into play. Later, we will revisit the same mechanisms in more scientific detail with research insights.

How One Seed Produces Mosaic Flowers (Accessible Explanation)

Let’s start by imagining a single seed of Mirabilis jalapa as it grows. Inside that seed is an embryo – a tiny plant-in-waiting – carrying genetic instructions from its parents. Typically, we’d expect all the flowers on that plant to follow those same genetic instructions and thus have similar colors. Yet, Mirabilis routinely breaks this expectation by producing mosaic flowers and multi-colored displays on one plant. How can this happen without involving any new pollen or outside genetic input? The answer lies in several fascinating within-plant processes that create variation during the plant’s own development. We will explain these processes in plain language:

1. Random color “switches” during growth (somatic mutation and chimeras): As a plant grows from seedling to mature bush, its cells are constantly dividing. Once in a rare while, a mistake or change can occur in the DNA when a cell divides – this is called a somatic mutation (a mutation in a body cell, not a seed). If that mutation happens in a gene that affects flower color, it can create a “branch” of the plant with a different instruction for color. For example, imagine our original seed’s DNA said “make pink pigment.” If one cell in a young branch accidentally acquires a mutation that knocks out that pigment gene, all the flowers that develop from that cell’s lineage might turn out white or yellow (lacking the pink pigment). Conversely, a mutation could occasionally activate a new color. The result is a genetic mosaic: the plant becomes a patchwork of cells with slightly different genetic makeup. One branch (descended from an unmutated cell line) might produce the usual light-colored flowers, while another branch (where a mutation occurred) might produce darker flowers. In extreme cases, a single flower can be part mosaic – if the mutation happened in one of the cells that gave rise to the flower bud, part of that flower’s petals will be a different color than the rest. Gardeners sometimes call these “sports” or chimeras – portions of a plant that suddenly sport a new trait. In M. jalapa, such spontaneous color shifts can lead to sectors or stripes of alternate color on a bloom. Importantly, these changes are not initially in the seed; they arise during the plant’s growth, effectively creating new variation from the same root. So one key reason many light and a few dark flowers can occur on one plant is that somewhere along the way, a cell in a stem “decided” (by mutation) to follow a different color program, and that decision was carried forward into all flowers on that stem.

2. Unstable color genes (“jumping genes” turning pigment on/off): Not all color variation requires a permanent DNA mutation; some of it comes from genes that act like fickle switches. Mirabilis jalapa is famous in genetics because it helped scientists discover transposable elements, often nicknamed “jumping genes.” These are pieces of DNA that can move around within the genome, sometimes inserting themselves into important genes and disrupting them, and later excising (jumping out) and restoring gene function. Think of a jumping gene as a tiny interrupting “paragraph” that can drop into a recipe – say, the recipe for making a red pigment. When present, it garbles the instructions and the cell can’t cook up that red pigment, resulting in a lighter flower (often yellow or white because only the base pigment remains). But later, if in some cells that transposable element jumps back out, the instructions become readable again and those cells can start producing red pigment. The visual effect is striking: you get a mostly light-colored petal with spots or streaks of a darker color where the gene switched back on. It’s as if most of the flower was painted one color, but randomly some brushstrokes of a second color appear. These random spots are not planned by the plant – they happen because in a few cells, a previously silent color gene got re-activated midstream. Many plants show such variegation due to jumping genes (for instance, variegated colors in morning glories, petunias, and carnations can come from this). In four o’clocks, scientists have indeed found that an element like this is behind red/yellow bicolor flowers (we’ll detail that later). For now, in simple terms: one Mirabilis plant can have many light-colored flowers as the “default” because a color gene was mostly off, but a few flowers or petals turn dark if that gene manages to turn back on in some sections. The pattern of on/off can vary from flower to flower, giving the mosaic of pure and spotted blooms.

3. Differences in cell layers and flower development: Another subtle cause of mosaic patterns is how flowers develop from layers of cells. A flower on M. jalapa isn’t actually made of petals, but of a modified calyx (sepal tissue) that behaves like a corolla[10]. The flower’s colored part comes from a few layers of cells in the bud. If some of those layers carry a different genetic makeup (say, due to a mutation or jumping gene as described above), the flower can open with sectors of different colors. For example, half of a flower might be one color and the other half another, if the two halves traced back to different initial cell lineages. Gardeners sometimes see half-and-half four o’clock flowers – literally split down the middle into two colors. This is often because one of two initial cell layers in the bud had a color mutation. Similarly, striped flowers (“flakes”) can result if a mutation or gene activation happened a bit later, affecting strips of cells as the petals expanded. In essence, the timing and location of a color gene change during flower formation will dictate the pattern – early changes yield big sectors (halves or quarters of a flower), later changes yield small spots or streaks. So, from one seed, as the plant branches and forms many flower buds, each bud has a tiny element of chance in how its color pattern might develop depending on any cell differences. This is why you might see one flower that is solid pink, next to another that is pink-and-white striped, next to another that is almost all white with one pink fleck – all on the same plant.

4. Environmental and physiological influences: While genetics play the leading role in Mirabilis color patterns, we shouldn’t ignore simple physiological factors that can cause color variation. The pigments in four o’clock flowers are sensitive to cellular environment. For instance, the color a pigment appears can change with cell sap pH or other biochemical conditions. Gardeners have noticed that as a Mirabilis plant ages, some flowers open a different shade than earlier ones – a known example is a yellow variety that produces deeper pink blooms later in the season[11]. This isn’t a genetic change, but likely an accumulated effect of the plant’s metabolism or soil conditions (perhaps a change in pH or pigment concentration causing the pinkish hue to emerge from a yellow background). Likewise, temperature and sunlight can affect pigment production – cooler nights sometimes intensify colors in flowers, whereas extreme heat might dilute them. So, one reason a plant might have many pale blooms and only a few darker blooms could be that most flowers opened during hotter days (coming out paler) and a few opened during cooler periods (coming out more intense in color). This effect is subtle compared to the bold mosaics from genetic chimeras, but it contributes to overall variation. Also, if a plant is stressed or nutrient-deficient, some flowers might not develop full pigment (looking lighter) compared to others on a well-fed branch. Thus, the plant’s internal physiology and environment create a background of variation on which the genetic mosaics appear.

In summary, even without any cross-pollination or new seeds involved, a single Mirabilis jalapa plant has multiple avenues to generate floral variety: random mutations in growing shoots can produce new color traits on some branches; jumping genes can turn pigment production off and on in speckles; the layered growth of flowers can partition different colors into one bloom; and changing conditions as the plant blooms can shift shades over time. These factors explain why from one genetic individual (one root), you often get many light-colored flowers (if a pigment gene is mostly off or a branch had a mutation for no pigment), some darker flowers (if a mutation or gene activation restored pigment in a branch or section), and a few spectacular spotted ones (where pigment turned on in just a smattering of cells). It’s as if the plant were an artist experimenting with its palette on each new flower.

Now that we’ve looked at the plant’s own developmental bag of tricks, we should consider the second part of the puzzle: pollination and genetics between plants. Up to now, we assumed no outside influence – but in gardens and nature, flowers are often pollinated by others. How does that influence the color variations we see?

How Cross-Pollination Influences Flower Colors (Accessible Explanation)

Imagine now that our four o’clock plant isn’t alone in the garden. Suppose nearby there’s another Mirabilis with solid deep-red flowers. When the hawk moth comes around one evening, it might visit a red flower on that neighbor plant and then carry some of that pollen to a newly opened flower on our original multi-colored plant. If that pollination takes, the seed that forms on our plant is now a cross between two different parents. What effect will that have when that seed grows into a new plant? Cross-pollination is essentially nature’s way of shuffling the genetic cards, and for traits like flower color, it can produce new combinations or restore lost traits. Here’s how cross-pollination can contribute to maintaining or enhancing variation:

1. Mixing different color genes – more combinations: Mirabilis jalapa has a range of flower color genes – some that lead to yellow (or white) pigments and some that lead to red (magenta) pigments, as well as pattern-controlling genes. If our original plant was mostly yellow-flowering (perhaps lacking a functioning red pigment gene) and it’s cross-pollinated by a red-flowering plant (which has a working red gene), the resulting seeds will inherit both versions of the gene. In the next generation, those seeds could grow into plants that have both pigment pathways available. Often, when Mirabilis inherits a “red” allele from one parent and a “white” allele from another, the flowers come out intermediate or mixed in color – e.g. pink. (In fact, Mirabilis jalapa is a textbook example of incomplete dominance in genetics: crossing a red-flowered plant with a white-flowered plant typically yields offspring with all-pink flowers, since the single dose of red pigment gene only produces a medium amount of pigment, not the full red of two doses.) So cross-pollination can introduce intermediate hues that neither parent showed alone. More generally, when plants cross, their offspring display greater genetic diversity: one seed might get gene combination A (leading to solid yellow), another gets combination B (spotted pink), another C (solid red), and so on. The mosaic of colors that a single parent plant achieved through somatic tricks can often be recreated (and expanded) in a population by having different seedlings express different genetic combinations. Cross-pollination essentially ensures that the population as a whole doesn’t become uniform – each seed is a unique individual with a potentially unique flower color pattern.

2. Spreading and sharing the “mosaic” trait: If one of the parent plants has an unstable color gene (like a jumping gene or a mutable allele), cross-pollination can spread that trait to new plants. For instance, suppose our original plant’s beautiful spotted flowers are the result of a jumping gene in its genome. If it self-pollinates, it might pass that jumping gene to its seeds (depending on whether the reproductive cells had it active or not – sometimes tricky, as we’ll discuss scientifically later). But if it cross-pollinates with another plant, there’s a chance to share that unstable gene with new genetic backgrounds. Some of the offspring may inherit the transposable element and thus have the capacity to produce variegated flowers as well. Meanwhile, some seeds might inherit a stable version from the other parent and produce solid colors. Either way, cross-pollination ensures the potential for mosaic patterns isn’t confined to just one lineage. It’s as if the rare “paint-splatter” gene from one plant gets distributed into others, keeping the trait alive in the broader gene pool rather than possibly dying out if that one plant failed to reproduce. This is important because some of those mosaic traits might not always pass on reliably when selfed (for example, if the spotted pattern was due to a rare mutation in only one branch’s cells, only seeds from that branch carry it). By exchanging pollen with others, the chances improve that at least some progeny carry forward the novel trait.

3. Avoiding inbreeding and pigment loss: Over generations, if M. jalapa were to only self-pollinate, it could become inbred. Inbreeding often leads to loss of diversity – recessive traits can become fixed and variation can diminish. For flower color, one risk of continual selfing is that a plant that, say, has mostly white flowers (due to a recessive non-pigment gene) will produce seeds that also all have that gene and gradually you get a pure line of white-flowering plants. That’s fine if you want only white flowers, but it means the delightful mix of colors might be reduced. Cross-pollination injects new alleles and prevents any one color from completely dominating unless it has a strong advantage. In nature, Mirabilis likely experiences a mix of self and cross pollination[9]. The crossing helps maintain a balance: for instance, if there’s a gene for “no color” (white) and a gene for “color” (red), random cross-breeding will ensure many plants are heterozygous mixes of these, often showing intermediate pink or both phenotypes, rather than all plants ending up homozygous one way or the other. Thus, from a gardener’s perspective, allowing cross-pollination between differently colored four o’clocks is a way to preserve the full spectrum. It can reintroduce lost colors (a white lineage crossed with a red can re-create pinks, salmons, etc., in the next generation) and generate new spot patterns when different unstable genes meet.

4. Within-plant pollination vs between-plant pollination: A special note on Mirabilis biology – sometimes a single plant can, in a sense, “cross” with itself if it has distinct genetic sectors. Recall our earlier scenario where one branch mutated to produce red flowers while the rest are yellow. If a moth takes pollen from a red flower branch to a yellow flower on the same plant, the resulting seed will unite two slightly different genetic makeups (because the egg from the yellow flower branch might carry the “no pigment” version, while the pollen from the red branch carries a “pigment-restored” version). This is still technically self-pollination (since it’s one plant), but due to the mosaic nature of the plant, it’s almost like a half-cross between two variants. That seed might end up being heterozygous (carrying one gene from the mutated branch and one from the non-mutated). In effect, a variegated M. jalapa plant can sometimes generate diversity in its own seeds by virtue of having multiple genotypes in different flowers – it’s a really clever way nature can preserve variation even in one individual! However, this depends on the plant actually having those internal differences reach the germ cells (pollen or ovules), which is possible but not guaranteed for every mutation (some mosaics might be only in petals, not in reproductive cells). True cross-pollination between separate plants is a more robust way to mix genes.

In more everyday terms, a gardener might notice that seeds collected from one very speckled four o’clock flower don’t all grow into speckled-flowering plants. Some seedlings might be plain, some might have different colors. That’s because the pattern was partly a product of that parent plant’s unique situation, and only some of the genetic factors for it passed on. But if the gardener had allowed bees or moths to pollinate flowers from many plants together, the seed batch would likely yield a wide array of colors and patterns – a richer diversity – because cross-pollination brought in more genetic possibilities. Conversely, if one keeps seeds year after year from only the same self-pollinated plant (especially if it’s a mostly uniform one), the line might stabilize to a particular color and you lose the surprise mix. Thus, cross-pollination is key to maintaining the carnival of colors in four o’clocks over generations.

So, to answer the question posed earlier: will picking only the prettiest patterned flower and propagating it reduce variation? Over time, it could, because you might be narrowing down to one genetic line, possibly losing the rainbow of alleles that other less flashy siblings had. The safest way to keep variation is to encourage lots of pollination between different color forms, or to gather seeds from many flowers (not just the fanciest one). But let’s not get ahead of ourselves – we’ll revisit that in the conclusion with preservation methods.

Now that we’ve explained in general terms how a single plant’s internal mechanisms and cross-pollination contribute to the phenomenon (many light flowers, fewer dark, rare spotted ones), it’s time to delve deeper. In the next sections, we will repeat these explanations with scientific detail, citing botanical research. We’ll see exactly what studies have discovered about those “jumping genes,” the genetic inheritance of variegation, and other technical aspects. If you’re not as interested in the technical nitty-gritty, you can skip ahead to the section on the life cycle – but for those with scientific curiosity, read on for a more detailed tour of Mirabilis jalapa’s genetics and biology.

Mechanisms of Floral Mosaic: Scientific Details (No Cross-Pollination)

In this section, we focus on the mechanisms that produce mosaic and patterned flowers within a single Mirabilis jalapa plant’s life, ignoring cross-pollination for the moment. Essentially, we’re zooming in on that first half of the explanation but now using proper botanical and genetic terminology, and we’ll cite research that has investigated these phenomena.

Somatic mutations and periclinal chimeras: Botanists have long observed bizarre cases where an individual plant seems to “change its genetic tune” partway through life. In M. jalapa, one of the earliest formal genetic explanations came from Carl Correns in the early 1900s. By 1910, Correns described how a homozygous plant could give rise to a heterozygous sector within itself – essentially articulating the idea of somatic mutation creating a mosaic individual[12]. In modern terms, a branch or a sector of a flower that differs in color often corresponds to a somatic mutation in a pigment gene. For example, consider the gene responsible for producing a betacyanin (red) pigment. If a mutation occurs in a single cell of a meristem (growth tip) that inactivates this gene, all cells derived from that mutant cell will lack red pigment. If that mutated cell is on one side of the meristem, it can lead to a periclinal chimera – where one layer of tissue (say, the outer layer of the flower petals on that side) has a different genotype than the inner layer or the other side[13][14]. The result might be a flower that is half red (from tissue that did not mutate) and half yellow/white (from the mutated cell lineage). Engels et al. (1975), who conducted extensive breeding studies on M. jalapa, noted that various authors had proposed explanations for variegation, but none was fully satisfactory until they revisited the genetics experimentally[15][16]. They confirmed that the plant’s somatic chromosome number is 2n = 58, indicating polyploidy[17], which can mask mutations to some degree (polyploid plants have multiple copies of each gene, so a mutation in one copy might not show effect unless others are also mutated). Nonetheless, Mirabilis clearly expresses variegation through somatic differences. Notably, Engels and colleagues set up crosses to see if variegation could be inherited; one inference from their work (and Correns’ earlier work) is that a somatic mutation must occur early in a cell lineage (preferably in a cell that gives rise to germ cells) to be passed to seeds, which is relatively rare[18][19]. More often, somatic mutations explain the mosaic display on the plant itself, but not all of those mosaics make it into the next generation.

A concrete example: suppose Mirabilis has a gene “R” needed for red pigment. If our seedling was R/R (homozygous for pigment), it would normally be red-flowering. If in one branch a mutation turns one R into r (nonfunctional) in a cell, that branch might become a mix of R/r. Because of polyploidy (perhaps it’s tetraploid, so maybe RRRR -> RRRr), pigment might diminish but not disappear; but if multiple hits or a loss of expression in that sector happens, that part could appear yellowish (betaxanthin only). Correns (1905, 1910) essentially observed such transitions and surmised the genetic mosaic nature[20]. Modern geneticists can even sequence different branches to detect such somatic differences, but in 1934 H. M. Showalter already concluded from breeding experiments that flower variegation in Mirabilis was not due to something like varying chromosome numbers, but must be due to more subtle changes[21][22] (he noted yellow pigments occur in all cells and the variegation wasn’t explained by aneuploidy[22]). This hints that the cells genetically program for pigment differently, not that one flower has more chromosomes or anything simplistic.

Transposable elements causing variegation: The most illuminating modern discovery in M. jalapa mosaic coloration is the identification of a specific transposon (transposable element) that interrupts a pigment gene. Suzuki et al. (2014) investigated a cultivar of M. jalapa that had red spots on a yellow background and pinpointed the molecular cause[23][24]. Mirabilis jalapa uses betalain pigments (not anthocyanins) to color its flowers. In betalain-producing plants, one crucial enzyme for red pigment (betacyanin) is CYP76AD (a cytochrome P450 enzyme converting L-DOPA to cyclo-DOPA)[25]. Suzuki’s team found that the normal red-flowered plants have a gene MjCYP76AD3 with an intron of a certain sequence, whereas the variegated red/yellow flower mutant had a transposable element called dTmj1 in that intron – and interestingly, it had been excised in the variegated tissues[26][24]. In plain language, the yellow background occurs because the transposon sitting in the pigment gene disrupts it (no red pigment made, so petals default to yellow from betaxanthins), and the red spots occur where the transposon jumped out, restoring the gene’s function in those cells[27]. This was the first report of a transposon causing variegation in a betalain pathway[23][24]. Prior to that, many variegated flowers in anthocyanin-producing species (like spotted petunias or striped corn kernels in maize) were known to result from transposons in color genes[28]. Now Mirabilis joins that club. The dTmj1 transposon in Mirabilis is classified as a Class II DNA transposable element (likely a cut-and-paste type) and is non-autonomous[29] – meaning it can move if some other element supplies the transposase enzyme. So, in a variegated four o’clock, the pattern of spots is essentially the “footprints” of this transposon hopping out in some cells but not others. Researchers note that the excision from the intron might not always perfectly restore the gene – often transposons leave a small signature. But apparently even imprecise excision in the intron was enough to allow pigment production in those cells[30]. This mechanism elegantly explains why, on the same plant, most flowers might be light-colored (transposon still inserted in pigment gene in most cell lineages), some entire flowers or branches turn dark-colored (if the transposon excised early in a branch’s development, that whole branch’s flowers have the functioning pigment gene), and a few flowers show sectored or spotted patterns (late or partial excision events creating a mix of pigmented and unpigmented sectors).

For instance, if dTmj1 jumps out in a cell in the flower primordium when the petals are just starting to form, that cell’s descendants – maybe a wedge of the petal – will be red, while the rest remain yellow. If it jumps out even later, just a small spot of a petal might get red. If it jumps out in the meristem that gives rise to a whole flower bud early on, that entire flower could be red (a rare dark flower on an otherwise yellow plant). Notably, if it jumps in a cell line that also goes into pollen or ovules, the excised (reactivated) gene could be passed to seeds; but if it doesn’t, the seed will inherit the transposon still in place. Suzuki et al. did sequence analysis confirming the presence of dTmj1 and its precise insertion site[31][27]. This gives us a concrete genetic model: Mirabilis jalapa variegation can be caused by a specific unstable allele at the color locus. Earlier genetic work by Spitters et al. (1975) had indeed postulated a “genetic system of flower variegation” possibly involving an unstable element[32]. They speculated about a controlling element that could cause irregular pigment sectors (their paper 6, as cited, was subtitled “speculation about its existence” of such a system). The discovery of dTmj1 validates those speculations: there is a genetic element whose excision creates the patterns.

Beyond this specific transposon, other molecular events can mimic its effect. For example, in some plants variegation comes from insertion of retrotransposons or even from epigenetic silencing that occasionally lifts. The common thread is unstable expression of a pigment gene. In carnation flowers, researchers found transposon excisions from flavonoid biosynthetic genes associated with variegation[33][34], analogous to Mirabilis. So scientifically, we describe Mirabilis jalapa with variegated flowers as carrying a mutable allele of a pigment gene – one that can spontaneously revert in somatic cells. It’s not random magic; it’s the material action of a mobile DNA sequence.

Polyploidy and gene dosage: The fact that M. jalapa is polyploid (58 chromosomes, likely tetraploid or aneuploid)[17] means each plant has multiple copies of each gene. This can affect mosaic expression. For example, a mutation in one copy might not visibly affect color if other copies compensate. This could explain why some flowers of Mirabilis are not just sharply red vs white, but often you see intermediate shades like peach or pink. In genetic terms, incomplete dominance arises – a single functional gene dose gives a diluted color. Correns himself documented cases of “intermediate” inheritance (which was one of the first reports of incomplete dominance in plants, using Mirabilis as the example)[35]. In a somatic context, a branch that is chimeric (mix of mutated and non-mutated cells in layers) might have a flower that looks somewhere between the two colors due to the layers blending. We might see a flower with a base color and a blush of another – that could be due to one tissue layer still making pigment and another not, resulting in a two-tone effect that the eye perceives as blend. Technical studies, such as those by Van Kester et al. (1975), also looked at pigment distribution and chromatography of different color sectors[36]. They likely found that betacyanin (red pigment) is either present or absent in sectors, whereas betaxanthins (yellow pigments) are probably present in all (hence even a “white” Mirabilis flower is usually a very pale yellow if you extract it, because of some betaxanthin). Indeed, Showalter in 1934 noted “yellow pigments occur in all cells”[22] – meaning the absence of red pigment reveals the underlying yellow background, and that doesn’t change; what changes is presence/absence of the red/violet betacyanin.

Epigenetic silencing and gene expression variation: Another mechanism that can create within-plant variation is epigenetic change – a gene being turned off not by mutation, but by chemical modifications (like DNA methylation) that are sometimes reversible. While there’s no specific published report of epigenetic variegation in Mirabilis jalapa, it’s a known phenomenon in other ornamentals (e.g., “flower color breaking” in certain strains can be due to methylation patterns that are unstable). Mirabilis could conceivably have some epigenetic component, but the evidence points more to genetic (transposon) causes for its variegation. However, one might consider the color-changing with age phenomenon (yellow flowers turning pinkish late in the plant’s life)[11]. This could be due to regulatory genes that change expression over time. Perhaps as the plant matures or as nights get cooler later in the season, certain enzymes in the pigment pathway ramp up or different pigment ratios are produced. From a biochemical perspective, betacyanin and betaxanthin production can compete for the same precursors. If a plant gradually shifts its enzyme activity (for instance, producing more of the betacyanin-synthesizing enzyme later on), a flower that would have been pure yellow earlier might now accumulate enough betacyanin to appear orangish or pinkish. This temporal mosaic (variation over time in the same plant) is another layer of diversity.

Virus-induced variegation: Though not reported specifically in M. jalapa flowers, it’s worth noting in scientific context that some flower variegation in other species is caused by viruses. For example, certain tulip variegations (“broken tulips”) were famously caused by potyvirus infections that affected pigment production in streaks. A review on double-color flowers notes that viral infections can lead to bicolored phenotypes in some ornamental plants[37]. In Mirabilis, a phytoplasma infection has been documented causing witches’-broom symptoms[38], but not known for petal color breaking. If Mirabilis were infected by a virus that selectively inhibits pigment in some cells, it could in theory produce a mottling. We mention this for completeness: a gardener might mistakenly think their four o’clock’s spots are disease, but in the case of M. jalapa, it’s usually genetic, not pathogenic.

To summarize the science for this section: Within a single Mirabilis jalapa individual, genetic mosaics arise from somatic mutations and transposon activity, creating sectors of different genotypes (and thus different colors). Studies have identified a specific transposon interrupting the betacyanin pathway gene, confirming the molecular basis of spotted flowers[27]. Historical genetics work supports that these variegations are not due to whole-chromosome changes but gene-level changes that can make a formerly uniform plant into a chimera[22]. The polyploid nature of M. jalapa and general pigment biochemistry add nuances – intermediate shades and the ever-present yellow base pigment. In short, the plant can self-variegate through these mechanisms. Next, let’s turn to how incoming pollen and cross-breeding factors overlay on this scenario scientifically.

Cross-Pollination and Genetic Diversity: Scientific Details

When we bring pollination between different plants into the equation, classic Mendelian genetics and population genetics come into play. For Mirabilis jalapa, flower color inheritance has been studied for over a century, as it’s an exemplar of non-Mendelian ratios in some cases (due to incomplete dominance and maternal effects on leaf variegation). We’ll break down the key scientific points on how cross-pollination influences variation:

Mendelian inheritance of color alleles: In the simplest genetic model (ignoring transposons for the moment), Mirabilis flower color is often described by alleles that show incomplete dominance. A famous example in genetics textbooks: let R be an allele for red petals and r be an allele for no pigment (white). Mirabilis heterozygous (Rr) for that locus produces pink flowers – a blend of red and white, thus demonstrating incomplete dominance. This was first quantitatively shown by Correns in 1905, soon after Mendel’s laws were rediscovered[35]. Engels et al. (1975) also studied uniformly colored flowers (red, yellow, white) and their crosses[18][19]. They found that the heredity of these colors could be traced to a few loci. One locus likely controls the presence/absence of betacyanin (red) and another might affect betaxanthin (yellow) intensity. A plant with genotype yielding no betacyanin but normal betaxanthin would be yellow; one with betacyanin would be red or magenta (magenta is basically red betacyanin plus some yellow betaxanthin mixing to give a fuchsia color). Indeed, they described forms: white, hues of red, hues of yellow, and variegated combos[39]. They also mentioned a tricolor variant (white/yellow/red sectors in one flower)[40], which suggests multiple layers of genetic control or multiple simultaneous mutations.

When cross-pollination happens between different color strains, the segregation of alleles in the next generation yields a range of phenotypes. For example, crossing a pure red (RR for pigment) with a pure white (rr) yields all Rr (pink) in F1; selfing those F1 yields offspring in a 1:2:1 genotype ratio (RR : Rr : rr), corresponding to red : pink : white in phenotype – a classic incomplete dominance result. Engels and colleagues likely observed similar patterns[18]. They aimed to lay the groundwork of uniform color genetics as a basis to tackle the variegation genetics[41]. In their major study (Spitters et al. 1975), they deduced a genetic system for variegation that likely involved more than one locus. Specifically, if a transposon is involved, one locus could be the pigment gene, another could be an element regulator.

Heterozygosity and retention of variation: From a population perspective, cross-pollination in Mirabilis jalapa helps maintain heterozygosity. Mirabilis is self-compatible and often self-pollinates, which means a single plant can seed itself and produce fairly uniform progeny if it’s homozygous. However, natural populations and garden plantings often have multiple Mirabilis individuals close by, and pollinators can cause outcrossing. Cruden (1973) observed that in weedy stands of Mirabilis, although selfing is common, the visitation by insects means geitonogamy and allogamy also occur at meaningful rates[9]. This results in a mixing of gene pools. Cross-pollination essentially reintroduces allelic variation into each generation. For traits like flower color, this means the offspring of crosses may display new recombinations. For instance, if one parent had the transposon-induced variegation allele and the other parent had a stable allele for solid color, some offspring might get one of each. Interestingly, what happens if a plant has one copy of a transposon-interrupted allele and one normal allele? If the trait is dominant (one normal allele suffices to make pigment), then that plant’s flowers might mostly appear solid (because the functional allele covers for the nonfunctional). However, if the transposon excises somatically, even a heterozygote could show spotting (though less obvious perhaps). In any event, crossing broadens the genetic canvas.

Engels et al. in their breeding program crossed variegated with solid and observed outcomes[42][43]. They likely noticed that variegation doesn’t follow simple Mendelian ratios, because it’s not a straightforward allele – it’s an unstable condition. Spitters et al. (1975) proposed that an interaction of genes was at play, possibly a two-element system (like a transposon and its regulator)[32]. If cross-pollination occurs, some progeny might inherit both elements and show variegation, some might inherit only the pigment gene without the transposon and thus be solid color. This yields a situation where variation is partitioned among progeny – not every plant will be variegated, but some will, preserving the trait in the population even if others become uniform.

Cytoplasmic inheritance – a side note on leaf variegation: Mirabilis jalapa has another famous type of variegation, in its leaves, which is due to chloroplast mutations. Correns (1909) showed that when Mirabilis has variegated green and white leaves, the inheritance is maternal – the ovule’s cytoplasm (with chloroplasts) determines whether offspring are green, white, or variegated[44][45]. This is because chloroplast DNA in the egg can be a mix (green and mutant white plastids). While this is a bit tangential to flower color, it underscores the complexity of inheritance in Mirabilis. If a variegated-leaf plant is used as a seed parent, some seeds might not germinate or might produce albino seedlings (if they got only defective plastids)[46]. For flower color, however, plastids are not directly responsible because betalain pigments are synthesized in the cytoplasm and stored in vacuoles, not in chloroplasts or chromoplasts like carotenoids. The Flickr comment we saw earlier speculating that petal variegation was due to chloroplast distribution[47][48] is likely incorrect scientifically for Mirabilis petals. Betalain pigments do not reside in chloroplasts; they are in the cell vacuole and their synthesis is enzyme-driven (CYP76AD, DOPA-dioxygenase, etc.) in the cytosol. So unlike leaf variegation, petal variegation in Mirabilis is nuclear-controlled. We mention this to avoid confusion: a cross involving a variegated-leaf mother could yield all-green offspring if the branch providing the seed was pure green sector (Correns demonstrated this), but that doesn’t directly influence flower color genes (which segregate in Mendelian fashion via pollen and ovule nuclei).

Maintaining transposon activity through crossing: One might wonder, if a jumping gene is so important, couldn’t it be lost? Yes, if a plant without the transposon or with it immobilized becomes common, variegation could disappear. Cross-pollination is a way both to propagate and to dilute such elements. Some offspring from a cross will inherit the transposon; others might not. There may also be regulatory genes that control the transposon’s activity (e.g., a transposase source). If two lines are crossed, it might bring together a transposon and a transposase that weren’t together before, potentially activating variegation anew. In snapdragons (another plant known for unstable flower color patterns), breeders maintained lines with certain transposons (like Tam elements) to get streaked flowers. In Mirabilis, we don’t have evidence of active management like that historically, but natural crossing likely allows the transposon to persist in some fraction of the population, popping up as spotted flowers here and there each generation, rather than one lineage selfing to purity and losing it.

Pollinator preferences and selection: Science also tells us that pollination isn’t purely random – pollinators may show preferences that can affect which plants cross. A recent study by Berardi et al. (2013) on Mirabilis jalapa color morphs found that hawkmoths (prime pollinators for four o’clocks at night) showed a preference for lighter (yellow) flowers over red flowers[49]. They also found differences in pollen tube growth: pollen from red/magenta morphs grew longer on certain styles than others[50][51]. These subtleties suggest that in a mixed-color population, there could be selective pressure balancing the colors. If pollinators favor yellow, yellow-flowering plants might set more seed. However, those same researchers found that high betacyanin (red) content correlated with better herbivore resistance in leaves[52][53], which might give red plants a survival edge. Such opposing selection pressures (pollinators vs herbivores) can maintain a polymorphism in the population[54][49]. This means from a genetics perspective, Mirabilis may be under natural selection to keep both “high-betacyanin” (red) and “high-betaxanthin” (yellow) types around[55][49]. Cross-pollination in this context ensures gene flow between the types, so the population doesn’t split entirely, but selection ensures neither allele frequency goes to 100%. The result: persistent color variation in wild or feral populations.

To put it concretely, if a population had mostly pale-flowered selfing individuals, they might suffer more herbivory, giving any darker mutant an advantage – but if too many are dark, pollinators might start favoring the occasional light ones, etc. It’s a dynamic equilibrium.

In summary, scientifically, cross-pollination introduces genetic recombination and heterozygosity which can create new solid colors and new variegation patterns in the next generation. The inheritance of variegation is complex but has been shown to involve a transposon in Mirabilis. With crossing, some progeny inherit that transposon and continue the mosaic trait[27]. Others may inherit stable alleles, contributing plain colors – but those can recombine in future crosses to again produce mosaics. The key point is that genetic diversity is preserved through crossing. Inbreeding would reduce it: for example, a selfed line of Mirabilis might eventually lose the spotted trait if it segregates out, or become fixed for one color. Crossing reintroduces lost alleles (like bringing a recessive white and a dominant red together yields pink hybrids, etc.). Thus, from a geneticist’s standpoint, continuous cross-pollination (outcrossing) is vital for maintaining the breadth of phenotypes in Mirabilis jalapa.

Having covered both the developmental mechanisms and the genetic cross mechanisms in detail, we have a solid understanding of how variation arises and is maintained in four o’clocks. Now, let’s integrate this knowledge by looking at the natural life cycle of Mirabilis jalapa. We will go stage by stage through a typical year (or years) in the life of the plant, noting at each stage how variation can be generated, filtered, or preserved. This will ground our discussion in the actual experience of the plant in the wild or garden, before we conclude with practical tips for preserving its charming diversity.

The Life Cycle of Mirabilis jalapa and Variation at Each Stage

In the wild (and in gardens), Mirabilis jalapa is a perennial herb that survives through a thick, tuberous root and through abundant seeds. Let’s chronologically trace its life cycle – seed → seedling → vegetative growth → flowering → pollination → seed set – and see how variation plays a role in each phase.

1. Seed Dispersal and Dormancy: Four o’clock flowers, after pollination, yield one-seeded fruits that look like wrinkled black nutlets[56]. Each seed is fairly large (~5-10 mm), hard, and falls near the parent plant when the dried flower drops off. There isn’t a specialized mechanism for long-distance dispersal; seeds mostly just drop to the ground (gravity dispersal). Occasionally, animals might move them inadvertently (they are not particularly fleshy or appealing to birds, though rodents might carry them a short distance). In tropical regions, there’s often not a long dormancy – seeds can sprout in the next rainy season. In temperate gardens, seeds that drop at end of summer will typically lie dormant through winter and germinate in late spring when soil warms (some might not survive winter wet/cold; gardeners often collect and store them dry). Variation aspect: At the moment of seed drop, each seed carries whatever genetic combination resulted from its parental cross. If the plant was self-pollinated, the seeds may be genetically quite similar, but if cross-pollinated, each seed could be a different hybrid. So, in a patch of volunteer four o’clock seedlings, you often see a spectrum of colors because the mother plant may have been pollinated by different fathers, and/or was genetically variegated herself. There is no further mixing at this stage – diversity is “locked in” to the seeds’ genomes until they grow. One thing to note: seeds from variegated-flower plants don’t necessarily produce variegated offspring. As discussed, it depends on if the underlying cause (like a transposon) was transmitted. For example, seeds from a yellow-with-red-spots flower might mostly grow into plain yellow or plain pink plants; the mosaic might or might not appear. In natural populations, this means the frequency of variegated individuals can fluctuate. But enough seeds are produced (each plant can produce dozens if not hundreds of seeds over a season) that the population as a whole retains a variety of genotypes, some of which will show interesting patterns.

2. Germination and Seedling Establishment: Mirabilis jalapa seeds germinate readily when conditions are right – warmth (around 18°C or higher) and moisture trigger them[57]. They often germinate within 1–3 weeks of planting[58]. The seedling sends down a taproot that will swell into the tuber. Initially, the seedlings have a pair of opposite leaves (cotyledons that can be reddish on their undersides if it’s a pigmented genotype[59]). Very early on, there’s little visible variation except perhaps stem and leaf tint: seedlings inheriting genes for high betacyanin may have a reddish hue on stems and cotyledons[59], whereas those lacking those genes are plain green. Indeed, Vosselman et al. (1975) studied pigment in cotyledons and hypocotyls as minor subjects[60] – they likely identified genetic control for red pigmentation in those tissues. A keen observer can sometimes predict flower color from seedling stem color: a seedling with purple-tinged stem likely carries the gene for magenta flowers (though not always a guarantee). At this stage, developmental variation hasn’t kicked in yet – all cells of the seedling stem from the original embryo, so any somatic mutation would have to occur during those first few divisions to create a noticeable sector. It’s possible (though uncommon) to see a half-green, half-variegated seedling if the embryo itself was chimeric (for instance, if the egg cell already had a sector of cells with a mutation because the mother plant’s ovule was variegated – something that can happen if a mutation occurred in the ovary wall). However, in practice, one usually doesn’t see variegated leaves on seedlings unless plastid variegation was involved (which is maternal). So at germination, variation is mostly genetic differences between seedlings. Some seedlings might grow faster or taller (vigor differences often correlate with heterozygosity – a product of cross-pollination giving hybrid vigor). Others might be runts. If seeds came from a selfed parent, most seedlings may look uniform; if from cross, some variation in growth and early pigment may show.

3. Vegetative Growth and Root Development: Once established, M. jalapa seedlings enter a rapid growth phase, especially if in warm sun and rich soil. They branch and form a bushy habit about 2–3 feet tall/wide (up to 1 m or more)[61][62]. They also develop a fleshy tuberous root that can become huge (older plants have been found with roots weighing tens of pounds)[63]. During vegetative growth, we might observe leaf variegation in some plants. As mentioned, leaf variegation (green and white patches) is typically due to plastid mutations and is maternally inherited. So only plants whose seed came from a variegated-leaved mother will show that. It’s a separate phenomenon from flower color, but relevant to variation: some plants in the population could have white-splashed leaves (which might weaken them a bit due to less chlorophyll), while others are fully green. Correns’ classic experiments involved taking cuttings or seeds from branches with different leaf colors to demonstrate maternal inheritance[64]. For our focus, leaf variegation is a curiosity but doesn’t directly create new flower color patterns (though a severely variegated, weak plant might produce fewer flowers or smaller blooms, indirectly affecting display).

Now, as stems grow and produce nodes, here is where somatic mutations or transposon events can accumulate. Every time a stem cell in a growing tip divides, there’s a minuscule chance of a replication error or a transposon jump. Over thousands of cell divisions, a few events are almost certain. If one of those events confers a visual change (like turning off a pigment gene in that cell’s lineage), a portion of the plant will carry it. So during vegetative growth, a Mirabilis individual can become a genetic mosaic. For instance, if around the 5th node a mutation occurs in the L1 layer of the meristem that knocks out the red pigment gene, then all flowers formed from that layer beyond that point might be white/yellow sectors on the petals. The plant might not flower until later, but the groundwork for a patterned flower is already laid in how the tissues partitioned. Some researchers have literally taken cuttings of differently colored branches to root and see if they “breed true” to that color – a method to isolate somatic mutations. M. jalapa can be propagated by cuttings or tuber division[65], so a branch that sported a new color can be separately grown. This has horticultural implication: if you get a unique patterned branch, you could dig up the tuber and cut off the portion corresponding to that branch and replant it, possibly yielding a plant that mainly produces that pattern (though due to the nature of transposons, patterns can still reoccur spontaneously). In the wild, though, such clonality is less relevant; the plant’s tuber will yield the same individual next season if it survives, but seeds are the main propagation. Variation at this stage also comes in the form of plant size, branchiness, and vigor – traits which have genetic components too. Some color morphs might grow differently; e.g., Berardi et al. found differences in leaf area and biomass among color morphs[66][67], indicating pleiotropic effects of pigment genes on growth. A red-pigmented plant might grow slower (they observed possibly slower growth for high betalain plants)[66]. So by the time of flowering, individuals are not only varied in color genes but also in overall phenotype.

4. Flowering and Anthesis: Mirabilis jalapa typically starts blooming in mid-summer (earlier in tropics) and continues through fall until frost. Flower buds are produced in clusters at stem tips (often 3–7 per inflorescence)[4]. Each flower opens in late afternoon (hence four o’clock) and lasts through the night, wilting by next morning[4]. The flowers are funnel-shaped with a limb about an inch across[68]. Importantly, the color and pattern of each flower is determined during its development in the bud. This is when any variegation becomes visible. Let’s break down possibilities: – A flower can be solid colored: This happens if all layers of the floral tissue have the same genetic instruction – e.g., the plant (or that branch) is uniform for pigment production (either producing pigment uniformly or not producing it). – A flower can be sectorial variegated (half-and-half or in big blocks): This results from genetic differences across the circumference of the flower, usually tracing back to a difference between cell layers or sectors in the early bud. For instance, if the L1 cell layer of the meristem carries a mutation and L2 does not, the edge vs center of the flower might differ in color (since in many plants, L1 contributes to outer petal tissue, L2 to inner). In Mirabilis, the entire corolla is essentially one whorl, but still, development from a ring of initial cells can cause half patterns. Such a pattern might present as a stark split color down a petal or between petals – these are the striking half-red, half-yellow blooms sometimes seen[69][48]. – A flower can have stripes (flakes): This suggests that during the expansion of the petals, some cells in a radial file lost or gained pigment ability. For example, a transposon excision might occur in a cell lineage that runs as a streak. Or if a mutation happened a bit later in development in one sector of the petal, that sector appears as a streak of a second color. Botanists sometimes use the term “striped” for these longitudinal variegations. – A flower can have spots: These are usually small clusters of pigmented cells on a different color background. They indicate very late or very localized activation/inactivation events – like transposon excisions in individual cells or small cell groups after the petals formed. They could also result from things like random X-inactivation-like patterns or viral local lesions (though virus is not known here). – A flower’s color can change over time after opening: It was noted that some Mirabilis flowers darken or change color as they age (white to lilac, yellow to orange-pink)[11]. This is a physiological change within the flower. One reason is likely oxidation of pigments or pH changes in the petal as it ages. Betaxanthins (yellow pigments) might deepen in color or betacyanins might synthesize slowly. There is also a phenomenon in some flowers (like certain morning glories) where pH shifts cause a visible color change (blue morning glories open pink and turn blue as pH rises in cells). Possibly in Mirabilis, as the flower ages overnight, some pigment concentrations shift, so by morning the color looks richer or different. This temporal variation means a flower you saw at 8pm might look a different shade by its wilt at 10am next day. However, by that time pollination is usually done, so it might not have ecological significance beyond being an observation.

During flowering, pollinator interactions come into play. As mentioned, M. jalapa scent and timing attract moths. Moths tend to prefer lighter-colored flowers in low light because they are more visible (a yellow or white flower stands out at dusk more than a dark red one). Indeed, Hirota et al. 2012 found hawkmoths prefer yellow Mirabilis over red[49]. So, what can happen is that flowers of certain colors get pollinated more frequently. If yellow flowers get more visits, they might set more seed. However, Mirabilis is so prolific that even red flowers will usually get some visits (hummingbirds or maybe a beetle or after-dark moths may still visit red ones especially if they still have scent). But this differential can introduce a subtle selection: plants with more yellow blooms might have a reproductive edge in a given environment. On the plant level, many Mirabilis produce both types, so it ensures at least some “beacon” blooms.

5. Pollination and Fertilization: M. jalapa flowers have no true petals but the colorful funnel acts like one big petal structure. The stamens (usually 5 or so) stick out with anthers, and a single pistil with a capitate stigma protrudes. Pollinators like hawkmoths hover and extend their proboscis to the flower’s base to drink nectar, touching anthers and stigma. Pollen can also self-deposit: Mirabilis flowers often have a bit of self-pollen transfer if not actively cross-pollinated (anthers can contact the stigma or pollen can fall on it). Cruden (1973) measured that self-pollination is common in four o’clocks[7]. So, fertilization can occur via: – Autogamy (within same flower): The flower’s own pollen fertilizes the ovule. This might happen if the flower doesn’t get a visitor; eventually, as it wilts, the structures might contact or just enough falls. Selfing maintains the genotype exactly (apart from new mutations). Variation is not introduced; in fact, it tends to make offspring more uniform and homozygous. – Geitonogamy (between flowers of same plant): A pollinator might carry pollen from one bloom to another on the same plant. Genetically, this is still selfing because both flowers are from one individual (unless the plant is a mosaic with differences, as discussed). However, here an interesting possibility: if our plant is a mosaic (say one branch has a pigment gene mutation), pollen from a red flower branch could fertilize an ovule on a yellow flower branch. Genetically, that is like crossing two different genotypes, albeit from the same plant. The resulting seed could be heterozygous where the parent was effectively heterozygous in different parts. So geitonogamy in a chimeric plant can produce novel combos. Engels et al. (1975) recognized this, noting that some variegation patterns could be transmitted via such crosses in controlled conditions. – Xenogamy (cross-pollination between different plants): This is the classic outcrossing. Each plant may have a different color genotype. When cross-fertilized, we already covered how that yields new combos. If a yellow-flowered plant crosses with a pink-flowered plant, the seeds might yield a range of colors depending on allele interactions.

Now, an important event after pollination is fertilization of the egg to form the zygote. In Mirabilis, only the egg’s nucleus and sperm nucleus combine; the cytoplasmic content (like plastids) in the egg largely comes from the mother. So maternal inheritance of leaf variegation occurs here: a variegated ovule (with mixed plastids) yields variegated seedlings. But for flower color, nuclear genes from both parents will dictate the seedling’s flowers. We should mention double fertilization (common in flowering plants) produces the embryo and endosperm. The endosperm nourishes the embryo and sometimes expresses genes too. In maize, for example, endosperm genes can show “xenia” (pollen affects kernel color immediately). In Mirabilis seeds, the endosperm isn’t visibly showing flower color, so no direct xenia. However, interestingly, in some plants there’s a phenomenon called metaxenia where pollen source can affect fruit tissue characteristics. It’s not known in Mirabilis (the “fruit” is just the seed coat essentially), so we can skip that.

Variation during fertilization can also come from random assortment of polyploid genomes. If Mirabilis is tetraploid, gametes might have various allele combinations. That’s deep genetics, but basically crossing high-polyploid individuals can produce a lot of genotypic variation in seeds.

6. Seed and Fruit Development: After fertilization, the flower withers and a single achene-like fruit forms. If the flower was variegated, one might wonder: does the pattern of the flower affect the seed? The seed coat in Mirabilis is derived from maternal tissue, specifically the ovule’s integuments. If those had sectors (say part of the flower’s pistil had a mutation), the seed coat might theoretically reflect that (like half seed coat color differences, etc.), but Mirabilis seed coats are uniformly black or dark when mature, so we don’t notice any pattern. And seed coat color is probably not varied by these pigment genes (different pathway). So seeds from any color flower all look similar. Thus, there’s no immediate visual sign on the seed of what color the flower was.

However, if one collected seeds separately from different color mother plants, one might find differences in germination or seed size. For example, some studies indicate pigment genes might have pleiotropic effects – perhaps seeds from red plants are slightly smaller or larger? There isn’t specific data on that, but Berardi et al. did examine aspects like seed germination time among color morphs (they noted high-betalain morphs took longer to germinate and had slower early growth)[66]. So, yes, there could be differences even in seed phase due to the genetic differences.

Cycle repeats: In warm climates, Mirabilis jalapa can behave as a perennial: the tuber stays alive underground over winter (in mild frost or no frost) and resprouts in spring. When it resprouts, it’s the same genetic individual as before – so any somatic mutations it accumulated, it still has. If last year one branch sported a mutation and that branch eye is still on the tuber, it may regrow that sector. Tuberous propagation thus can perpetuate a mosaic individual for years. In colder climates, the tuber may not survive frost unless dug up (gardeners often treat it like dahlia tubers and store them). If left, the plant relies on seeds to overwinter the lineage. Each seed then grows as a new individual in spring, potentially far from the parent if transported or just next to it if dropped. Over time, a stand of Mirabilis can naturalize – you might find a cluster of them of mixed colors, which essentially are all self-sown descendants with lots of recombination from occasional outcrossing.

Loss and maintenance of variation: Summing up across the life cycle: – At seed phase: variation enters via parent genetics; some potential narrowing if selfed (line becomes uniform). – At seedling phase: survival might cull some variants (for instance, an albino seedling from variegated mother will die – thus that variation is lost immediately; this happens with plastid variegation, where white seedlings are not viable, maintaining only green or green-white ones in population). – During growth: new variation can appear (somatic mutation, transposon action). Also, competition might eliminate weaker individuals – if one color morph grows slower (as found, high pigment might slow growth[66]), perhaps fewer of them reach flowering in a competitive environment, reducing their frequency. On the other hand, herbivory might selectively take out more of the tender, less pigmented ones (insects might avoid redder leaves[52], meaning yellow/green forms suffer more damage). So there’s a natural selection filter here that can shift the ratios. – Flower stage: pollinator selection can favor certain colors for reproduction. This doesn’t kill plants, but it biases whose genes get into the next generation (e.g., if moths prefer yellow, yellow’s genes (including “no red allele”) get spread more). – Pollination stage: cross-pollination actively maintains or increases variation by combining lines; selfing tends to reduce it by isolating lines. The mix of these in a population sets how much new combo arises. – Next generation seeds: hold the new combinations, ready to sprout and continue the cycle.

Given this cycle, wild populations of Mirabilis jalapa (in places it’s naturalized like some subtropical areas) show polymorphism: you often see a mixture of colors present, not a monomorphic stand. This indicates that neither pure selfing nor extreme selection wipes out diversity; the plant’s biology fosters a dynamic equilibrium of many colors. Humans cultivating Mirabilis have also enjoyed this by often growing mixed seed packs that result in a colorful display.

Now that we have a full picture of how Mirabilis jalapa lives and maintains its charming variation naturally, we can turn to practical matters. Suppose you are that gardener who loves the spotted marvel-of-Peru and you want to ensure that you keep getting such beautiful variety in your flowers year after year, rather than accidentally narrowing it. What can you do? In our final section, we will outline some simple intervention methods to preserve (or even boost) variation in four o’clocks. These methods will be straightforward and low-tech – things you can do by hand in your garden – aligned with the natural processes we’ve discussed. We’ll also throw in a few general care tips to keep your Mirabilis plants happy, since healthy plants tend to produce more flowers (and more opportunities for delightful variation!).

Simple Methods to Preserve and Enhance Variation in Mirabilis jalapa

One of the joys of growing four o’clocks is never knowing exactly what colors or patterns you’ll get – it’s like nature’s surprise package each evening. To keep that genetic and phenotypic diversity flourishing in your patch, consider the following hands-on strategies. These methods mimic or assist natural processes like cross-pollination and selective propagation, ensuring that no single type takes over to the exclusion of others:

• Encourage Cross-Pollination by Hand: As we’ve learned, cross-pollination is key to mixing traits and generating new color combinations. While moths and other insects do a decent job at night, you can play pollinator too – especially if you have a particular pairing in mind. A very simple technique is to perform reciprocal rubbing of stamens between flowers of different colors. For example, if you have a yellow-speckled-with-red flower and another plant with solid magenta flowers, try creating a “mosaic marriage”: in the early evening when the blooms have just opened and the pollen is fresh, gently pick a stamen (the thread-like filament with anther) from one flower and brush it onto the stigma (the sticky knob) of the other flower. Then do the reverse: take a stamen from the second flower and dust it onto the first flower’s stigma. This hand-pollination takes only seconds (you can even just pluck off an entire flower from one plant and swab it onto another bloom). No special tools are needed – your fingers or a small paintbrush can transfer pollen as well. By deliberately crossing a richly pigmented bloom with a patterned bloom, you increase the chance that the seeds will produce offspring with a mix of those traits. Remember to label or note which flowers you crossed if you want to track the results (you can tie a little thread on the flower’s stem). The next summer, you might find some of those seedlings carrying the coveted spots or novel color shades thanks to your intervention.
• Save Seeds from Many Different Flowers: It’s tempting to collect only the seeds from that one jaw-dropping spotted flower and ignore the rest. But to preserve overall lineage diversity, practice inclusive seed saving. When the plants start forming black seeds, gather a mix: pick seeds from solid-color flowers and from variegated ones, from different plants if you have multiples. Mix all these seeds together for sowing next season. This way, you maintain a broad genetic base. The beautifully spotted flower’s seeds might or might not yield spotted children (due to the fickleness of the transposon gene), but among a big, diverse seed batch, chances are some offspring will display interesting patterns. The goal is to avoid a genetic bottleneck (narrowing to one line). By sowing a variety of seeds, you’ll get a kaleidoscope of plants – some perhaps plain, some boldly patterned, some new shades altogether. Over successive years, continue this practice of “open-source” seed saving, which mirrors how a wild population maintains diversity.
• Propagate Unique Variants Vegetatively: If you do encounter a one-in-a-million pattern that you absolutely adore (say a yellow flower perfectly dusted with red freckles) and you fear its seeds won’t come true, you can attempt to preserve that exact individual through cloning. Mirabilis jalapa can be propagated by cuttings or division of its tuber. In fall, carefully dig up the tuberous root of the plant with the special flower (if climate allows, or if it’s in a pot). You can divide the tuber if it’s large – making sure each piece has at least one growing “eye” or bud node (much like dividing a potato or dahlia tuber). Alternatively, in summer, you can take a green cutting from a non-flowering branch of that plant, stick it in moist soil, and it may root. These vegetative methods will create clones of the parent, theoretically preserving its genetic makeup (including any somatic mutation that caused the pattern). Next year, plant that tuber or cutting, and it should produce the same style of flowers. Now, note that due to the unstable transposon, the pattern might still vary (the clone might throw some solid or differently spotted blooms, as mosaic patterns can recur spontaneously), but the propensity for that pattern is retained. This technique is a bit more advanced and optional, but it’s a way of locking in a unique genotype. Once you have a clone, you can again cross it with others to distribute that trait.
• Promote Bee/Moth Activity (Avoid Bagging or Restricting Flowers): Some gardeners bag blooms or isolate plants to ensure purity of a strain. In our case, we want the opposite – let the pollinators do their thing freely. Make your garden friendly to the evening pollinators: planting night-scented flowers (which you already have in four o’clocks) and providing habitat for moths can help. Avoid using pesticides at dusk when moths are active. The more natural pollinator visits between different plants, the more genetic mixing. So, plant four o’clocks in groups where different color varieties are adjacent. This way, a single moth visit might inadvertently cross several colors in one evening. A patchwork arrangement (rather than segregating colors on opposite ends of the garden) fosters cross-pollination. If you have only one plant, consider swapping some seeds or pollen with a fellow gardener who has another color – effectively simulating cross-pollination at the seed stage.
• Rogue Out Uniform Offspring (if preserving diversity is goal): If over time you notice that a particular line is dominating – for example, say you ended up with many self-sown seedlings that are all solid light pink and none of the fun colors are appearing – you might practice a gentle form of selection: rogue out some of the overly common type to make space for others. This means you might intentionally not save seeds from the most common plain plants or even remove a few seedlings of that type to allow rarer ones to flourish and set seed. This is a bit like what nature does via herbivory or pollination bias, but you can guide it. That said, don’t eliminate them entirely; they might carry hidden alleles needed for patterns. Just maintain balance. In general, however, Mirabilis is so variable that this drastic step is seldom needed unless one color truly takes over due to inbreeding.

Finally, while focusing on variation, don’t forget to simply care for the plants’ health, because robust plants produce more flowers and seeds, which inherently increases opportunities for variation to manifest. Here are a few general care tips to keep your four o’clocks happy (which in turn helps preserve their diversity):

• Water strategically, especially before peak bloom time: Four o’clocks can handle dry conditions (they have tuber reserves), but in very hot weather their leaves may wilt by midday[70]. A smart practice is to water in the early afternoon on scorching days – a few hours before they open – so that the plants are turgid and hydrated by evening. This ensures the flowers open fully and remain firm. Good hydration can also enhance pigment display; well-watered plants tend to have more vibrant blooms, and the petals are less likely to flag. Just avoid waterlogging – they like well-drained soil.
• Enrich the soil occasionally: While four o’clocks aren’t heavy feeders, giving them a nutritional boost can improve overall vigor. Vermicompost (worm castings) is an excellent gentle fertilizer to sprinkle around the base mid-season. It provides micronutrients and organic matter that strengthen the root system. Strong roots (and remember, Mirabilis has big roots) mean more growth and flowering. You can also use a root-strengthening supplement like seaweed extract or mycorrhizal fungi at planting time to help them establish a robust root network. A healthier plant will produce more buds – and more buds equate to more chances for interesting mutants or patterns to appear.
• Balance the nutrients – especially Phosphorus (P) and Potassium (K): Too much nitrogen can make them all leaves and few flowers. To encourage blooming and sturdy growth, apply a fertilizer higher in P and K (the last two numbers on N-P-K labels) if needed. Phosphorus supports flower development and root growth, while potassium helps with overall hardiness and can intensify flower color. For instance, a side-dressing of bone meal (for phosphorus) in early summer and a bit of wood ash or a balanced bloom fertilizer (for potassium) can be beneficial. Always follow label rates – Mirabilis doesn’t require heavy feeding. Think of it as giving them the right tools to paint their floral canvas richly.
• Support and space the plants: Although bushy, their branches can flop, especially if they get top-heavy with blooms or if in windy sites[62]. Provide a little support (like a ring or stakes) if necessary to keep flowers accessible to pollinators (not slumped on the ground). Also, if you plant multiple four o’clocks, give them room (at least 12–18 inches apart)[71] so they don’t overly compete; crowded conditions can stress plants and reduce flowering. Adequate spacing ensures each plant can display its full range of blooms (and it makes it easier for you to observe and select seed from individual plants of interest).

Using these methods, you essentially become a steward of the genetic diversity in your four o’clock flower bed. Over the years, you might even inadvertently “select” for a strain that produces lots of spotted flowers, simply by cross-pollinating those and saving their seeds. Or you might maintain a balanced mix by always including new seed stock from various sources. The key is, unlike in breeding for uniformity, here we are gardening for diversity – embracing the surprises nature gives and even amplifying them.

In conclusion, the story of Mirabilis jalapa and its multicolored blooms is a beautiful interplay between genetics, development, and human appreciation. From a single seed can arise an orchestra of color due to mutable genes and mosaic development, and through mindful gardening practices, we can ensure this orchestra doesn’t dwindle to a solo. Instead, it can remain a symphony – with light notes, dark notes, and those splendid unpredictable flourishes (the spotted notes!) that make the four o’clock flower truly the “marvel of Peru.”

By understanding the mechanisms behind the magic – from transposons hopping in a pigment gene[27] to moths favoring one color over another[49] – we not only satisfy our scientific curiosity, but also learn how to better cultivate and conserve the delightful variability of this plant. So next time you’re in your garden at 4 PM, and the Mirabilis blooms start unfurling, take a moment to appreciate the subtle genetic drama each flower represents. And if you see one that is especially striking, you now know how to help its legacy live on without diminishing the diversity around it. Happy gardening, and may your four o’clocks always surprise you!

References

(Throughout the text above, numbers in brackets refer to specific sources backing the statements, following the format 【source†lines】. Below is the list of sources cited, corresponding to those bracketed citations.)

1. Engels, J. M. M., van Kester, W. N. M., Spitters, C. J. T., Vosselman, L., & Zeven, A. C. (1975). “Investigations of the inheritance of flower variegation in Mirabilis jalapa L. 1. General introduction and 2. Inheritance of colour in uniformly coloured flowers.” Euphytica, 24(1), 1–5.[18][15]
2. Suzuki, M., Miyahara, T., Tokumoto, H., Hakamatsuka, T., Goda, Y., Ozeki, Y., & Sasaki, N. (2014). “Transposon-mediated mutation of CYP76AD3 affects betalain synthesis and produces variegated flowers in four o’clock (Mirabilis jalapa).” Journal of Plant Physiology, 171(17), 1586–1590.[23][24]
3. Tanaka, Y., Sasaki, N., & Ohmiya, A. (2008). “Biosynthesis of plant pigments: Anthocyanins, betalains and carotenoids.” Plant Journal, 54(4), 733–749. (Note: Discusses mutual exclusivity of anthocyanins and betalains in Caryophyllales and mentions transposon in Mirabilis).[29][27]
4. Cruden, R. W. (1973). “Reproductive biology of weedy and cultivated Mirabilis (Nyctaginaceae).” American Journal of Botany, 60(8), 802–809.[9]
5. Correns, C. (1909, 1910). Studies on variegation in Mirabilis jalapa. (Historical papers demonstrating cytoplasmic inheritance of leaf variegation and somatic segregation in flower color)[72][20]
6. Showalter, H. M. (1934). “Self flower-color inheritance and mutation in Mirabilis jalapa L.” Genetics, 19(6), 568–580. (One of the early genetic analyses of Mirabilis flower color; concluded variegation isn’t due to chromosome number variation)[22]
7. Berardi, A. E., Hildreth, S. B., Helm, R. F., & Winkel, B. S. (2016). “Betalain floral color morphs exhibit differential growth, defensive ability, and pollen tube growth rates in Mirabilis jalapa (Nyctaginaceae).” American Journal of Botany, 103(8), 1462–1473.[49][52]
8. Wisconsin Horticulture – Division of Extension. (2015). “Four O’Clocks, Mirabilis jalapa.” (Garden guide)[73][68]
9. Wikipedia. “Mirabilis jalapa.” (General information on description, patterns, and history)[2][11]
10. HortScience (2022). “Advances on the Coloring Mechanism of Double-color Flowers in Plants.” HortScience, 57(9), 1120–1130. (Review article that includes Mirabilis jalapa case)[27]
11. Eflora of India. “Mirabilis jalapa – Variegated flower images.” (Photographic references for variegated M. jalapa)[47][48]
12. Hollyhock Hill. “The Marvel of Peru, the Four O’clock Flower.” (Historical/cultural note on origin and Aztec cultivation)[1]

---

[1] [2] [3] [4] [10] [11] [44] [45] [57] [61] [70] [72] Mirabilis jalapa – Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirabilis_jalapa

[5] [6] [8] [56] [58] [62] [63] [68] [71] [73] Four O’Clocks, Mirabilis jalapa – Wisconsin Horticulture

Four O’Clocks, Mirabilis jalapa

[7] [9] [12] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [35] [36] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [46] [59] [60] [64] [65] (PDF) Investigations of the inheritance of flower variegation in Mirabilis jalapa L. 1. General introduction and 2. Inheritance of colour in uniformly coloured flowers

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/226447165_Investigations_of_the_inheritance_of_flower_variegation_in_Mirabilis_jalapa_L_1_General_introduction_and_2_Inheritance_of_colour_in_uniformly_coloured_flowers

[13] [14] Mirabilis jalapa – Wikipedia

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mirabilis_jalapa

[21] [22] Self Flower-Color Inheritance and Mutation in Mirabilis Jalapa L.

https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Self-Flower-Color-Inheritance-and-Mutation-in-L.-Showalter/5a5c54d6ee9636fdb9c24c6577c2ecb32c2bf568/figure/0

[23] [24] [25] [26] [28] [29] [30] [31] Transposon-mediated mutation of CYP76AD3 affects betalain synthesis and produces variegated flowers in four o’clock (Mirabilis jalapa) | Request PDF

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/264987309_Transposon-mediated_mutation_of_CYP76AD3_affects_betalain_synthesis_and_produces_variegated_flowers_in_four_o’clock_Mirabilis_jalapa

[27] [33] [34] [37] Advances on the Coloring Mechanism of Double-color Flowers in Plants in: HortScience Volume 57: Issue 9 | ASHS

https://journals.ashs.org/view/journals/hortsci/57/9/article-p1120.xml

[32] The inheritance of the mutable variegated leaf in Mirabilis jalapa L.

https://ouci.dntb.gov.ua/en/works/4yqYRyr4/

[38] [PDF] Phytoplasma infection in the four o’clock flower (Mirabilis jalapa)

https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/document?repid=rep1&type=pdf&doi=5fda58394b33ff87577524de82947aa97fd1df15

[47] [48] [69] Variegated Four o’clock sooc | Yes, straight out of the came… | Flickr

[49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [66] [67] Betalain Color Morphs Exhibit Differential Growth, Defensive Ability, and Pollen Tube Growth Rates in Mirabilis jalapa (Nyctaginaceae)

Click to access Berardi-et-al-2013-Mirabilis1.pdf