(playlist)
🦋🤖 Robo-Spun by IBF 🦋🤖
👻🪸🐈⬛ Phantomoperand 👻🪸🐈⬛
🎭♟️🕹️ Kukla Rejimi 🎭♟️🕹️
(Turkish, German)
Ballet is marketed as a showcase of European civilization, the geisha as a showcase of Japanese refinement, kabuki as a showcase of traditional theater, Kathak as a showcase of Indian classical art, and royal dances as a showcase of sacred heritage. Behind this display lie prostitution, the buying and selling of children, sexual exploitation, and adult domination over children’s bodies. At the Paris Opéra, wealthy men were granted privileged access to private areas occupied by female dancers. In Japan, girls were handed over to geisha establishments under debt-bound service contracts. In China, boys were trained for female roles, while some were offered to adult male customers for sexual exploitation. In India, girls could be drawn into sexual exploitation under the guise of religious dedication. Artistic training, debt, customer recruitment, and access to bodies all entered through the same door. Where a child is sold or offered up for sexual abuse, the rhetoric of cultural refinement is a curtain drawn over exploitation.
One of the most dangerous habits in accounts of this system is to portray the man as the person who buys and exploits, and the woman solely as the person who is bought and exploited. Where the documents show a woman making decisions as a mother, proprietress, palace administrator, art teacher, customer intermediary, or manager, the account can no longer be confined to the system to which she herself was subjected. The authority exercised by the woman, the money she collected, and the discipline she imposed must be recorded with equal severity. A woman who knowingly organizes the sexual exploitation of a child bears her full share of responsibility. The erasure of the female perpetrator is not a shortcoming that can be remedied by exposing the male perpetrator; it is the removal of half the machinery of exploitation from the historical record.
To blame this system on the morality of any single civilization is to clear the records of the others. In certain historical establishments associated with Japanese kabuki, Korean kisaeng, Indian courtesan houses, Ottoman köçek dancing, Cambodian royal dance, Indonesian folk dances, and Spanish flamenco, the questions that make the accounts add up are these: Who selected, trained, and sold the performer? Which adult found the customer, and how much did that adult demand for which service? Who took charge of the child’s life, drew up the contract, imposed disciplinary punishments, and collected the money? Where there is a male customer on one side and a female proprietress or mother on the other, the actions of each must be recorded separately. Which elements of the relationships built around prostitution, child labor, and abuse are being polished today under the name of cultural heritage? The accounting of complicity does not end with the customer; it extends to the adult who procured the child and collected the payment.
Cinema is not merely the narrator of this system; at times it is directly involved in running it. Hollywood and Indian cinema turned the geisha, the courtesan, and the cabaret dancer into symbols of beauty, love, sacrifice, and tragic nobility. Within the same industry, producers, studio executives, and managers attempted to make career opportunities for performers conditional on sexual demands. Images of child actors were sold through the commercial decisions of mothers, fathers, directors, and companies. Customer, patron, mother, teacher, executive, and intermediary are not innocent social labels here; they denote real powers over money, employment, and bodies.
To merge the roles of these adult women into a single ‘female experience’ is to erase the line separating their material positions. The girl being sold and the mother facilitating her sale, the young performer being placed in debt and the proprietress keeping the debt ledger, and the aspiring actor and the female executive wielding the power to distribute roles do not stand on the same side of the same transaction. One is subjected to the transaction while the other arranges it. The first question in a history of abuse is not who is a woman, but who signed off on which decision.
Edward Said’s account of Orientalism, and the critiques that apply it to geishas, harems, courtesans, and dancers, cannot be exempted from this reckoning. Investigating how a woman worked in a prostitution establishment reveals her contract, her customers, her income, how she was recruited as a child, and her employer. Concentrating instead on how that same woman was represented in a Western text directs attention to the text, the gaze, identity, and the audience. When the second inquiry replaces the first, the actual working life of a human being becomes scenery for a theory. That is what happens in some examples of the Orientalism literature: the records of the prostitution establishment recede, while the ideological analysis of the text describing it takes pride of place.
Throughout this article, the term ‘accomplice’ refers to the concrete actions of an adult who knowingly participates in the sexual exploitation of children, the sale of human beings, or coercive labor. Lumping girls and boys sold as children, performers held under duress, and all adults who make a living by providing sexual services into one guilty mass would distort those same material records. Precision means identifying the perpetrator through their own actions: one examines the person who sells, confines, coerces, or introduces the child to a customer, markets the child’s image, or collects a commission. Under this standard, female perpetrators bear full responsibility, rather than a reduced share assigned on account of their sex.
Opera and Geisha Houses: The Male Customer, the Female Proprietress, Prostitution, and the Power of Access
To view the nineteenth-century Paris Opéra solely as a temple of high art producing ballet and music is to erase the male privilege within the building from history. Elite male subscribers could enter a private area called the Foyer de la danse. The dancers’ rehearsal and backstage lives were opened to direct access by wealthy men. For mothers of girls from poor families, a ballet career was sometimes calculated in terms of the money a wealthy protector might provide. Discipline onstage and the market for patronage backstage existed under the same institutional roof.
The Parisian arrangement had two different doors: the wealthy man’s entrance through the foyer, and the family’s decisions over the poor girl’s career. The subscriber’s privilege explains the first; the family’s calculations in the hope of patronage explain the second. The conduct of a mother who stakes her daughter’s future on a wealthy man’s support must be investigated according to the substance of her decision. If the mother knowingly negotiated an arrangement exposing her child to sexual abuse, this is not ‘maternal sacrifice’ but adult participation in child exploitation. A record of an expectation of patronage alone, however, does not by itself prove such participation; precisely what must be investigated is whether, and through what concrete agreement, that expectation became a transaction.
In its exhibition on the history of prostitution from 1850 to 1910, the Musée d’Orsay in Paris names this relationship explicitly:
« l’Opéra est le théâtre d’une prostitution de haut vol »
[The Opéra is the theater of high-class prostitution.]
What the source describes is not a few customers who happened to be found in an artistic milieu: subscribers’ access to the dancers’ private spaces and paid sexual relations surrounding the stage were embedded in the social organization of this high-art institution. The splendor of the Opéra and the prostitution market operated side by side in the same building. To praise the ballet student’s training while passing silently over the system of male access and income that took shape around that training is to remove the most damning part of the history. (🔗)
The article Ballet: Human Puppeteering and the Orchestration of Universal Prostitution (🔗), which examines subscriber privileges around the Paris Opéra’s Foyer de la danse alongside child dancers’ vulnerability, bodily discipline, and the workings of the prostitution market, details how this same system was organized through doors, gazes, rhythm, and debt.
To the door–gaze–rhythm–debt chain described in that study of ballet, one must also add the line of decision-making between the child’s family and the establishment. Who brought the child to the stage? Who made the relationship outside rehearsals the subject of a bargain? Who profited from finding a ‘protector’? If the history of the ballet institution describes the demands of wealthy men while making the adults who bargained over the girl’s future invisible, it leaves the door at the very center of its account insufficiently described.
Japanese geisha houses, too, were institutions in which art, debt, patronage, and customer relations were intertwined. 置屋 (okiya) regulated a performer’s lodging, training, and attachment to the establishment. お茶屋 (ochaya) was the place where customers were entertained. 検番 (kenban) administered bookings and fee calculations. 旦那 (danna) was a wealthy male patron who financed some geishas. Each of these names identifies a distinct function; read together, they expose the network of money and authority beneath the language of beauty.
To describe an okiya merely as a place of lodging or artistic instruction is to downplay the establishment’s managerial authority. The hours a girl would work, the amount of debt charged to her, who would receive her earnings, and which customer’s demands she would be expected to meet are concrete questions about how the establishment operated. Where this authority was concentrated in a female proprietress, excluding her from history simply because the customer was male is tantamount to hiding the contract and the accounts ledger. If child selling, sexual exploitation, or forced labor is knowingly organized, the female operator is also an organizer of or participant in the system; she must not be cast as a protector merely because she is called a ‘mother’ or ‘teacher.’
The Japanese 日本大百科全書 (Encyclopedia Nipponica) names one historical branch of geisha work without circumlocution:
「踊り子という私娼」
[Private prostitutes known as dancers.]
The same source also records prostitution among urban geishas in these words:
「その売春もなかば公然と行われた」
[Their prostitution was also carried out semi-openly.]
Geishas underwent substantial artistic training in singing, dance, music, and conversation. These skills were only one side of the historical reality. In certain periods and establishments, those same skills became a means of attracting customers, while the name geisha became a commercial cover for the sale of sexual services. The Japanese historical source records that prostitution continued under the geisha designation and that earnings were shared with the establishment’s operator. The reality of artistic skill does not absolve the prostitution system attached to it; the two activities became sources of revenue for the same establishment. (🔗)
Moreover, the presence of artistic training and sexual services within the same institutional environment does not mean that every geisha did the same work; a history of wrongdoing requires asking who employed whom, and under what conditions. In cases where a proprietress wielded actual managerial power over girls, the limits of that power must be examined: Who entered a debt in the accounts under the heading of training costs, who controlled entry to and exit from the house, and what money was paid to whom? A transaction organized by a woman is as central to the history as a transaction purchased by a male customer.
Korea’s 기생 (gisaeng/kisaeng) system also places state coercion alongside patronage. The institutional setting in which women studied music and dance was the 교방 (gyobang). Kisaengs were employed in palace ceremonies and at banquets for government officials. Women assigned as 수청기 (suchŏnggi) could be required to provide sexual services to male officials. The Korean historical record states it plainly:
「성적 봉사를 해야 하는 수청기」
[Suchŏnggi who had to provide sexual services.]
Some kisaengs held the status of state slaves. The state trained and assigned these women, making some of them available to the sexual demands of male officials. The issue here is not merely the female dancer’s position before an audience; it is the regime of service that public authority imposed upon women’s bodies and labor. (🔗)
The privileged subscriber in Paris, the customer and danna in Japan, and the government official in Korea: in all three cases, access to the stage could extend into a right to interfere in the working life of a female performer. The performance drew a crowd, and the institution singled out men with money or rank from within it. One side of the world described as refinement contained a regime of privilege determining which man could approach which woman.
The earlier presentation of this comparison was all too suited to describing the customer while relegating the intermediary to a footnote. Yet just as important as a customer list is another record: which person or institution allocated access to the customer. For this reason, the administration of the okiya in Japan, the family and school milieu in Paris, and the state’s assignment mechanism in Korea must be examined separately. Where there is a female manager, her authority cannot be dissolved into a general category of womanhood; the orders she issued and the fees from which she took a share must be recorded.
Who Handed Over the Child? Mother, Proprietress, Debt, Training, and Sexual Exploitation
At the darkest point in this history stands the child. In certain practices of the Japanese geisha system, from the Meiji period through the early Shōwa period, girls of around ten were taken into establishments as 仕込み (shikomi); at twelve, they could move into the status of 舞妓 (maiko) or a similar young-performer status, and around seventeen they could begin working as full geishas. The young girl’s day was divided between artistic training, housework, and preparation for entertaining customers. The word training was well suited to obscuring the actual workload of children of these ages, their lives under supervision, and their upbringing with future customers in mind.
To describe a ten-year-old child’s entry into the profession merely as ‘admission’ is to leave the other side of the transaction blank. The adults who brought the child to the establishment, negotiated payment, received the advance, and pledged her future labor were the agents of this transaction. Where the child’s age and the term of employment are known, the investigation must go so far as to determine which family member signed which document. If the mother made the agreement, she must not remain under a softened category called mother; her actual role in the agreement must be recorded.
An advance debt called 前借金 (maekarikin) could be charged against income the girl had yet to earn. 年季奉公 (nenki-bōkō) meant an obligation to serve for a specified period. The operator took a contractual share of the earnings. The family’s receipt of an advance payment, the establishment’s charging of training costs, and the child’s eventual repayment of that account through her labor were parts of a single mechanism. Although this mechanism, which placed the child’s future in debt in advance, bore the respectable name of vocational training, its concrete reality was economic dependence.
The decisive act in this accounting of debt is the adult’s exercise of control over a child’s future labor to meet the adult’s own needs or the establishment’s expenses. Whoever received the money, administered the contract, or controlled the child’s ability to free herself from debt must have their responsibility investigated. If a proprietress calculates the debt and takes a share of the income, she is not merely an ‘instructor’; she is the establishment’s economic decision-maker. In concrete cases where debt-bound service and sexual exploitation converge, the female proprietress’s management of income becomes a point at which responsibility for exploitation must be accounted for.
増田小夜 (Masuda Sayo) is a firsthand witness who recounted being sold into a geisha establishment as a child. Her life is a forceful rebuttal to the narrative that recounts geisha culture solely through the elegant recollections of an elite artist. On one side stands a famous performer who built a career; on the other, a poor girl bound by an agreement between her family and an establishment. Both belong to the history of the same profession.
Masuda Sayo’s testimony is crucial for this reason: what happened to the child is not scenery for a success story; it is the direct subject of a purchase and employment relationship. Adults’ description of a girl as a ‘future artist’ cannot erase the record that she was sold as a child. The female proprietress’s artistic knowledge must be recorded alongside the economic power she held over the child’s body and labor.
In Cambodian royal dance, the age recorded in the sources is younger still. George Groslier, describing the reign of King Norodom, writes that girls as young as six were brought to the palace by their families:
« Leurs parents les lui amènent, dès l’âge de six ans. »
[Their parents bring them to him from as early as the age of six.]
Families could receive payments of between 20 and 500 piastres, depending on their daughters’ age and beauty and the king’s generosity. Girls who entered the palace faced severe restrictions on leaving. The king’s chief wife exercised authority over the dancers’ punishments, rehearsals, discipline, and payments. The dancers were trained within the harem system. The picture presented by these records is clear: a six-year-old child’s life was transferred to the palace hierarchy through a payment to her family, while her movements and labor were controlled by adults. (🔗)
In the Cambodian record, money paid to the family stands on one side, and the palace chief wife’s authority to punish and make payments on the other. The chief wife here is not merely a female figure beside the ruler; she is an administrator who personally directs children’s work. The actions of the adult who sets rehearsal schedules, imposes discipline, and controls payments must be assessed in her own right. The administrative authority shown by these records cannot serve as separate proof of sexual abuse; it is, however, powerful evidence in its own right of actual domination over children.
Praise for the sacredness of royal dance does not undo this material transaction. The king’s dance, offered to the gods, was organized through the removal of children from their families, payment for them, and their upbringing under harsh discipline. The chief wife and other palace women also exercised real managerial power over the lives of hundreds of dancers. Responsibility as perpetrator or intermediary in this system was not confined to the male ruler; adult women in the palace hierarchy were decision-makers as well.
In some families among the Badi communities of western Nepal, income from music, dance, and sexual services was pooled within the same livelihood system across generations. Itinerant performing families entertained local rulers and wealthy men; in later periods, some households became dependent for their livelihood on putting their daughters into prostitution. Field research also records the role of mothers in preparing their daughters for this work. Here motherhood and profit from a girl’s body confront one another within the same concrete case. (🔗)
In the Badi field account, a mother’s preparation of her daughter for this work must not disappear into a passive sentence such as ‘the fate of poor families.’ What work did the mother teach her, who took her to the customer, and who controlled the price? When the act of knowingly directing a girl into commercial sexual exploitation is established, the adult woman’s participation is full participation. Poverty explains the economic context of the sale; it does not erase the material record of an adult’s decision to sell or expose a child to abuse.
When family, a mother, or a female operator is involved, polite language that transfers responsibility to another adult makes the child invisible once again. Whoever delivers the child to an establishment, supervises her work, prepares her for customers, negotiates the terms, or receives the money is fully responsible for their own actions, regardless of sex. The complicity of a mother who knowingly directs her daughter into abuse, a female proprietress who knowingly manages a system of debt and sexual customers, or a female intermediary who receives commissions from abuse is not partial complicity. In cases where children are directed into sexual exploitation, this responsibility is all the more serious. Titles such as protection, upbringing, motherhood, and artistic training can become social disguises for actual mediation. To attribute guilt, the specific adult’s concrete decision, knowledge, and actions must be investigated.
Boys on Display: Kabuki, Peking Opera, Köçek Dancing, and Pedophilic Demand
The early history of Japanese kabuki contains a frank history of the sex trade behind its present-day image as prestigious classical theater. In the 遊女歌舞伎 (yūjo kabuki) performances of the early seventeenth century, women engaged in prostitution danced. The female performer’s appeal onstage was also turned into a means of attracting male customers. With the prohibition of women’s kabuki in 1629, performances by young males came to the fore. The sexual marketplace surrounding the stage changed form by changing the performers’ sex.
若衆歌舞伎 (wakashū kabuki) was theater performed by youths who had not yet attained adult male status. Their physical attractiveness drew customers; some sold sexual services. Where performers were children, an adult customer’s purchase of such services was plainly a matter of child sexual exploitation. The Japanese 新版 歌舞伎事典 (New Edition Kabuki Dictionary) records the reason for the 1652 prohibition as follows:
「これも衆道の売色を兼ねていたために」
[Because this also involved the sale of sexual services between males.] (🔗)
The 相公堂子 (xiànggong tángzi) establishments of Qing-era China provide an even more direct record of a system that prepared young male performers for exploitation under the name of training. Boys taken from poor families were trained to perform 旦 (dàn), or female, roles. A child played a female character onstage and, in some cases, was also handed over to meet adult men’s sexual demands. Artistic training, child selling, and demand from pedophilic customers could thus become linked.
In this record, the operator, the customer, and the supply chain between the child and the family must each be made visible. Selling a child is as much the act of the seller as it is that of the buyer. If a mother, father, or other adult relative participated in the decision to sell, each must be considered according to the evidence; automatic innocence is not assigned to a female relative, nor an automatic share of blame to a male relative. The stark historical claim here is this: When a child is sold to a theater and to a sexual customer, the transaction concealed under the expression ‘family choice’ is child selling.
The sentence in the Chinese account of theater history records the sale of children directly, rather than merely making a literary allusion:
「许多穷苦人家的孩子往往被卖到堂子去」
[Many children from impoverished families were often sold to these establishments.]
The same account states that some male opera performers who later became famous were forced to provide sexual services in such establishments at the beginning of their careers. The poverty of a child’s family became part of the operator’s supply channel, while acting training was tied to a network of sexual customers. In cases where the sexual abuse of children by adult men was organized through a theater establishment, calling that exploitation ‘the eroticism of tradition’ diminishes the gravity of the practice. (🔗)
Ottoman köçek dancing is another historical field in which young male bodies were trained for music, dance, and male entertainment. Köçek dancers performed in feminine clothing, with dance movements and music, in mansions, taverns, and private gatherings. In some circles, the young dancer’s erotic appeal was a principal selling point of the performance. Records concerning sexual services require separate investigation. The names çengi, köçek, tavşan, and civelek must each be examined to determine the ages, working functions, and customer relationships they designated. In every case where child performers were presented to satisfy adult demand, the question is not artistic style but abuse and mediation.
The practice of بچهبازی (bacha bazi) in Afghanistan is among the starkest examples of a system in which making boys dance and sexually abusing them occurred together. Powerful adult men made children dance at entertainment gatherings and sexually assaulted some of them. Reports concerning armed conflicts document verified cases of children held captive for these purposes. Here dance becomes the performance medium of pedophilic sexual exploitation; customer entertainment and child abuse unite within the same power relationship. (🔗)
The record of European opera also contains severe interventions carried out on children’s bodies in the name of art. In Italy, some boys were castrated to become castrati, in order to prevent their voices from deepening at puberty. Poor families set their sons on this path in the hope that they might one day become highly paid opera stars. An intervention with permanent surgical consequences for a child’s body was tied to adults’ expectations of career success and money. The splendor of certain singers who later became famous cannot erase from history an intervention whose price was paid in childhood. (🔗)
The family side of the history of the castrati raises the same question: Who consented to an irreversible intervention for the sake of the child’s voice, who encouraged it, and who hoped to profit? A parent’s concrete decision to direct a son down this path in the hope of a career forms part of adult responsibility. Evidence of sexual abuse and records of permanent bodily mutilation are not interchangeable here. The promise of an artistic career is not a permission slip that can normalize a severe bodily intervention imposed on a child.
The young performer presented to sexual customers in Japan, the boy sold to a theater establishment in China, the child sexually abused through dancing in Afghanistan, and the child castrated for an operatic voice in Italy are not examples of the same act. What they share is adults treating children’s bodies as material to be managed for projects of profit and performance. In cases of sexual abuse, pedophilia and sexual demand directed at children must be discussed explicitly; in cases of castration, bodily mutilation and coercive adult decisions are the accurate terms. Naming each practice according to the act involved is the first step in piercing these institutions’ armor of respectability.
Sacred Dance and Courtesan Art: The Proprietress, the Temple, the Palace, and the Conservatory
The history of Indian classical dance clearly shows the working arrangements beneath titles of sanctity and high art. The तवायफ़ / طوائف (tawaif) performers of northern India were trained in dance, music, Urdu poetry, and sophisticated conversation. मुजरा / مجرا (mujra) performances took place in entertainment houses called कोठा / کوٹھा (kotha). Wealthy men evaluated the women’s voices, dancing, beauty, and comportment. Experienced women could direct the training of young performers and, therefore, their future employment prospects. Artistic refinement emerged within these houses from a hierarchy of money, customers, and authority among women.
To present the adult women of the kotha world solely as ‘masters who transmitted tradition’ can itself become a form of respectabilization criticized by this article. Training a young performer, managing her earnings, choosing her customers, and restricting her freedom of movement are separate powers. A female operator is accountable for whichever powers she exercises. A woman training an apprentice and a woman directing a child into sexual exploitation have not committed the same act; but when the second act is documented, the title of master does not extinguish responsibility.
The labor of these courtesan circles is one of the decisive historical sources for the development of the Kathak repertoire. Dance and music financed by courts and urban patrons later became part of the foundational material of Indian classical art. Research drawing on Urdu and Persian documents records in detail the selection of tawaifs, their transfer to other courts, the regulation of their earnings, and intermediary relationships among the women themselves. To describe the respectable repertoire on the conservatory stage while erasing the actual financial and labor arrangements of the courtesan houses that nurtured it is to leave the history of the art half-told. (🔗)
In southern India, the dedication of girls to a deity or temple service within the देवदासी (devadasi) institution surrounded music and dance training with religious legitimacy. In certain regional practices, that dedication marked the beginning of children’s descent into sexual exploitation. Field research published in 2020 documents the lives of thirty girls who were dedicated as children and subjected to commercial sexual exploitation. If a girl’s path toward sexual abuse passes through a sacred dedication ceremony, sanctity is part of the language that conceals the abuse and secures acceptance of the child into the institution. (🔗)
The question of perpetrators left unanswered by accounts of temple dedication is which adult made the decision to dedicate the child on her behalf. What function did the family, religious official, local intermediary, or female administrator perform in this process? When the sexual exploitation experienced by thirty girls has been documented, speaking only about the abusive male customer leaves the channels of supply and supervision in darkness. In cases where adult women knowingly facilitated a child’s dedication, responsibility extends to their concrete decisions. Such participation cannot be attributed to any particular mother or devadasi performer without evidence of her role in the records.
As the sadir repertoire performed by devadasi artists passed into modern Bharatanatyam, both ownership and social status of the dance changed. The teaching and performance institutions established in the twentieth century transformed an art sustained by historical female performers into the prestigious classical repertoire of middle- and upper-class circles. The transfer from mahari temple performers to the modern stage in Odisha’s Odissi dance raises the same question: As an art’s status rose, which conditions of labor and dependence experienced by its historical performers were excluded from the narrative?
The movement of an art into upper-class culture does not turn all the women who once sustained it into a single victim or a single cultural hero. Within the same institution, the adult deciding on the child’s behalf, the operator managing training and income, the performer working to make a living, and the girl subjected to abuse may occupy different positions. The history of modern Bharatanatyam and Odissi requires describing each through their distinct actions. The invisibility of a female perpetrator is as serious a problem of historical writing as the appropriation of women’s artistic labor.
In the Javanese Bedhaya Ketawang tradition, sacred dance was intertwined with the ruler’s political and ritual power. Some female performers trained at court could be drawn into concubinage relationships. The king’s sacred potency, the woman’s role onstage, and the ruler’s private life converged within the same power structure. The sanctification of dance makes it even more important to identify separately and concretely the power the ruler exercised over women’s lives.
When the palace’s private life and sacred dance converge within the same institution, female members of the hierarchy must not be excluded from the account. If female court officials held powers of selection, supervision, training, or discipline, these must be recorded individually. Yet a woman’s mere presence at court does not automatically make her a perpetrator in the system of concubinage. The perpetrator’s identity is established through concrete orders, payments, and testimony. Rigor means scrutinizing the palace’s adult administrators through their own actions.
Korea’s 진주검무 (Jinju Geommu) sword dance offers an opportunity to trace the transition from an employment status to national heritage. A choreography preserved in kisaeng training circles received national cultural heritage status in 1967. The state service and working conditions of the female performers in the history of this carefully preserved dance are part of that same heritage. While the choreography is called heritage, the service regime to which the women who sustained it were subject must not be reduced to a historical footnote. (🔗)
The process of becoming classical is not merely a change of stage; it can also lead to the rewriting of a profession’s past. The repertoire developed by women who once lived as courtesans, temple attendants, or state entertainment workers becomes a source of national pride for later generations. One must therefore ask not only who created the dance, but who employed the woman who created it, from whom she received money, who selected the customers, and through which words this past is recounted today.
The Real Business of the Dance Hall: Female Intermediaries, Customers, Commissions, and Prostitution
In Indonesia’s ronggeng and tayub traditions, female dancers participated directly in performances with male customers. A female performer known as a taledhek danced for a male customer and received money in return. In some establishments of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, prostitution was added to the performance. This business world, in which dance fees and payment for sexual services coexisted, cannot be reduced to a folkloric tale of refinement.
Here, too, two positions occupied by women are easily confused: the adult performer paid for her dance, and the operator managing someone else’s work. The presence of the designation taledhek does not establish that a female performer coerced other women. But when records identify a female intermediary or operator organizing the prostitution market, describing her only as a ‘female bearer of entertainment culture’ leaves something out. Who worked, who managed, and who collected commissions? These are the material questions that dispel respectabilization.
The title of an Indonesian historical study calls the subject by its name:
Prostitusi Berbalut Seni
[Prostitution Cloaked in Art.]
The study recounts how tayub, which developed as a ritual and social dance, became connected to the prostitution market in certain historical settings. The incorporation of prostitution into art is not a remote interpretation here; it is the very title of a local historical study. (🔗)
Egypt’s الغوازي (ghawazi) women performed dance within the setting of urban entertainment and customer relations. In the nineteenth century, public female dancing and prostitution became targets of the same administrative interventions, showing how the state understood the commercial connections between the two activities. The Ouled Naïl dancers of Algeria likewise occupied a place in the entertainment economy of colonial cities through their jewelry, dress, performances, and sexual services. French colonial photography placed their images on the market as well. While a woman worked, someone collected money from the customer; while she posed, someone else sold her image.
Barkahoum Ferhati, who has studied the Ouled Naïl, considers actual prostitution relationships and the image of the dancer created by colonial tourism within the same history. The woman’s customer, local social ties, working life, and face marketed in photographs can be traced separately. Investigating women’s actual place in the prostitution market while the camera turns them into exotic images reveals the flow of money behind the scenery. (🔗)
Spanish flamenco offers another specifically European example. The nineteenth-century cafés cantantes attracted customers with dance, music, and alcohol. Some female performers met wealthy customers at private gatherings and engaged in prostitution. The establishment could derive revenue from the private relationship between a woman and a customer as well as from the onstage performance. Flamenco was later elevated to high-cultural status through concert halls, theaters, and conservatories. Today’s artistic prestige cannot remove the customer and prostitution relationships of historical entertainment establishments from the record. (🔗)
In the early tango world of Buenos Aires, dance academies, drinking establishments, and brothels were parts of the same urban economy. In some brothels, tango was a means of occupying waiting customers and fostering intimacy before commercial sexual encounters. The accusation antesalas o pantallas de la prostitución [anterooms or screens for prostitution], directed at nineteenth-century dance academies in Cuba, also makes this connection visible. These words were public accusations made at the time; a concrete historical inquiry must separately establish which practices existed in which establishments. (🔗) (🔗)
In the twentieth century, physical intimacy with a customer was divided into finer increments and assigned prices. In American taxi-dance halls, customers paid for each dance with a woman. The Brazilian taxi-girl system used dance cards. In Mexico, women known as ficheras increased an establishment’s revenue by dancing with customers and inducing them to buy drinks. Shanghai’s 舞女 (wǔnǚ) dancers worked through ticketing and customer relationships. London’s music-hall circles and South African shebeen establishments also brought performances, alcohol, and sometimes sexual services into the same commercial setting. Every form of physical intimacy had its own price, and every price had its own buyer.
Singapore’s lancing girls system reveals this accounting with almost the clarity of a ledger. Female dancers were paid to dance with a customer or sit at his table. Female intermediaries known as mummies could manage their working arrangements. According to a former customer’s account, some women went out with men at the end of the night, and the female intermediary received a commission from the hourly rate. The female operator’s authority here is not an indefinite social role: it consists in taking a share of the money exchanged between customer and worker.
The word mummy is especially misleading here: a title evoking maternal care and nurturing in English names a female intermediary who manages the monetary relationship between worker and customer. The account of hourly commissions collected when women were taken out with men shows the economic function of customer procurement. If ‘mummy’ is read as a protective title while the fact of commission is omitted, the female operator’s role is exonerated at the level of the word itself. Concrete testimony must separately establish in which cases this developed into forced labor or child abuse.
In the same oral-history study, a woman recounts how her mother took her to a dance hall in 1952, when she was only twelve, and appropriated her earnings. The employment of a twelve-year-old child, her mother’s involvement in the establishment, and the adult’s appropriation of the earnings converge in a single testimony. Here the child’s age and labor must be recorded first, followed by the responsibility of the adult who introduced her to the customer environment; the title of mother cannot serve as a cover for this transaction. (🔗)
The sharpest detail in the 1952 testimony is not the designation ‘dance hall,’ but the fact that a twelve-year-old child was taken there by her mother and had her earnings taken away. The person who took the child there was the mother; the person who appropriated the child’s earnings was again the mother. No other man’s actions are needed here to record the female perpetrator’s decision. Although this testimony alone does not prove that the child suffered sexual abuse, it directly establishes that child labor was used under economic domination within the family.
In Thailand’s a-go-go bars, some providers of sexual services are officially registered as entertainment staff. Customers meet women in the performance venue, and the sexual-services relationship may move into a private space. American soldiers’ demand for rest and entertainment during the Vietnam War played an important part in the spread of this commercial arrangement. Modern sex tourism carried certain marketing and intermediary practices from traditional dance and customer-entertainment economies into new circumstances. The word entertainment on a staff record does not, by itself, explain what the customer bought. (🔗)
A payroll describing someone as an entertainment worker does not negate the operator’s decisions about working conditions. Who hired the worker, who collected the money, and who directed the customer? In establishments where a female operator is recorded as managing these processes, regarding her merely as another woman like her employees erases the material substance of being an employer. Where sexual exploitation or coercion occurred, every adult perpetrator must be investigated according to their specific intervention.
The Clean-Name Operation of States and Cultural Institutions
In performance markets linked to prostitution, naming is itself an instrument of power. In Meiji-era Japan, geisha licenses and prostitution licenses were regulated under separate categories; the practical enforcement of these distinctions varied by region. In Korea, kisaeng work evolved from state service into commercial entertainment associations. In kabuki, prohibitions imposed on the early performer troupes associated with sexual services transformed the theatrical form. Laws and licenses give an activity a name; to understand the economic and sexual relationships occurring within the same establishment, one must look behind that name.
Naming also has a particular function in exonerating female perpetrators. When the adult keeping a child’s debt ledger is recorded as a ‘proprietress,’ the adult negotiating a fee with a customer as a ‘mummy,’ and the adult authorizing the trade in a child’s image as a ‘mother,’ the concrete acts performed by those persons can be softened. The title must be translated into an action: Who drew up the contract, who received the money, who locked the door, and who selected the customer? Blaming the customer while shielding the manager behind a refined professional title means writing the same institution’s history by two different standards.
British theater licenses, Spanish regulations governing entertainment establishments, and Indian prohibitions on temple dance likewise show the methods by which states drew boundaries between performance and sexual services. Twentieth-century conservatories, performance venues, and cultural heritage institutions selected parts of older repertoires and bestowed new titles of respectability upon them. The employment and customer relationships of one period reappeared under the heading of aesthetic tradition in the curriculum of another.
Cinema’s own records suffice to show how the name of a profession was changed. The 1937 film Marked Woman drew inspiration from organized prostitution in New York. When Hollywood censorship intervened, the prostitute characters in the screenplay were renamed nightclub hostesses. The film records directly confirm this change. The criminal economy of the story remained, while the profession’s name was cleaned up. (🔗)
There is a concrete linguistic similarity between the mechanism that renames a prostitute a ‘hostess’ in a film and the concealment of a woman’s intermediary authority under a maternal title in actual establishments. In the first case, censorship repackages the profession; in the second, an employment arrangement appears under another social term. There is no need to claim that the two constitute the same factual process: both are decisions about naming that determine which economic act a reader or viewer will see at first glance.
In this instance, cinema covered the prostitution relationship with the occupational language of the entertainment industry. The women remained within the same criminal world; the word the audience heard had changed. This shows how respectability can sometimes be produced by a remarkably simple operation: a word is removed from the screenplay and replaced with an acceptable occupational label.
A company’s license, a dance’s cultural heritage registration, or a profession’s censored name in a screenplay is not reality itself; each is a device that determines the words through which reality circulates. When prostitution is called hostess work, a child’s labor is recorded as training, and sexual access is described as patronage, the first thing that changes is what the audience sees.
How Did Cinema Turn Prostitution and the Courtesan into a Goddess of Love?
Hollywood’s recurring trick is this: it turns a sexual relationship established for money into the beginning of love, the courtesan into a self-sacrificing lover, and the commodification of the body into visual splendor. Even when the customer and the money do not disappear from the woman’s story, they acquire another meaning under the light of romance.
Adult women’s exercise of power can also disappear within this romantic appearance. When is the female manager of a brothel, the older proprietress, or the adult character who determines a girl’s fate portrayed as a ‘protector,’ and when as a ‘cruel but necessary instructor’? The roles of fictional characters are not evidence of historical institutions; nevertheless, one can examine directly which powers a film transforms into refinement and which bargains it turns into love scenes.
Pretty Woman is an example of this transformation that can be traced through the history of its screenplay. The film was originally titled 3000, a direct reference to the money a wealthy male customer paid the woman. In the first screenplay, the woman was left on the street again at the end of the relationship. The final film, developed with Disney’s Touchstone company, turned this dark story into a romantic comedy. The companionship purchased with money became the beginning of love. Expensive clothes and the opera house became cinematic signs proclaiming the woman’s rise in society. A relationship that began with a customer’s payment was turned into a fairy tale of salvation before the audience’s eyes. (🔗)
Satine in Moulin Rouge! is both the star of the stage and the woman at the center of a financing negotiation. The wealthy investor Duke demands private sexual access to Satine as a condition for financing the theater. Satine is a sparkling diamond in the performance, a self-sacrificing lover in the romantic story, and a body to be acquired in the investor’s bargain. The film turns this naked exchange into part of a love tragedy through magnificent music, costumes, and dance. The financing of an artistic institution and the sexual demand imposed upon a woman sit at the same negotiating table.
In The World of Suzie Wong, a woman engaged in prostitution in Hong Kong becomes an American painter’s model and the center of his romantic love. The prostitution world in which she works is presented anew through the painter’s aesthetic gaze. The lead actress’s ballet training also shows how classical bodily discipline meets cinema’s image of the courtesan. A woman from the prostitution market is transferred into an artist’s painting and the audience’s love story.
Memoirs of a Geisha turns a girl taken into an establishment as a child into a highly valued performer after years of training. Dance, kimono, makeup, lighting, and music are the glittering face of this ascent. The interest of male patrons, financial bargaining, and the arrangements by which the child is raised are woven into a narrative of romantic destiny. The history of economic dependence in the Japanese entertainment establishment is repackaged through the aesthetic of a big-budget Hollywood period film. The story of a girl handed over to an establishment as a child is sold to the audience primarily as a spectacular story of growing beautiful.
In this narrative, the little girl’s transformation is shaped not only by the male patron’s gaze, but also by decisions surrounding her admission into the establishment, upbringing, discipline, and preparation for adult customers. The presence of female characters who make those decisions cannot be brushed aside by calling the film ‘a story of female solidarity.’ Presenting the woman who controls the child’s life and the girl who must live that life as subjects of the same romantic destiny conceals the hierarchy at work. The fictional decisions made in the film must not be confused with historical okiya records either.
The Indian films Pakeezah and Umrao Jaan foreground a courtesan’s music, poetry, dance, and tragic love. Women’s purchase, training, and relations with male customers are elements of the historical kotha system. On film, however, this world is burnished with the elegance of classical culture. The courtesan associated with prostitution becomes a vessel of romantic sacrifice and refinement; the economic system dissolves into aesthetics.
In kotha narratives, the roles of adult women in teaching art, selecting customers, and administering commercial life must also be followed. The singing or dancing courtesan’s talent does not answer the question of who brought a young girl into the establishment. Even if a female manager is presented in fiction as someone who ‘preserves the tradition’ of the profession, her economic decisions must be examined individually. The gulf in authority between the woman providing the training and the girl receiving it must not be erased from the background of romantic tragedy.
Marlene Dietrich’s Lola Lola in the German film Der blaue Engel became a worldwide icon through her sexual appeal on the cabaret stage. In Hollywood’s Gilda, Rita Hayworth’s dancing and star image earned her the title Love Goddess. The sexualized female image from the stage now lived not only in entertainment venues but in cinema’s global marketing system.
What all these films share is an act of renaming through beauty. Sexual appeal, money, customers, and patronage relationships are aestheticized through music, makeup, costume, and romantic destiny. As the audience becomes attached to the woman’s artistry and tragedy, the economic structure of prostitution often recedes behind the image. Cinema’s light can become the most effective curtain of respectability drawn over a commercial relationship.
Behind the Screen of Acting: The Executive, the Mother, Sexual Blackmail, and Child Abuse
While telling other people’s stories of prostitution and abuse, cinema also produced sexual pressure in its own workplaces. Producers, managers, and studio executives who could secure roles, employment, and public visibility for actors were able to use those powers to make sexual demands. Where the power to provide employment is converted into a demand for sexual access, the romantic career fairy tale ends and a relationship of coercion and abuse begins.
Focusing on male producers in this section is likewise insufficient to explain the entire network of authority in the workplace. Female and male adults who summoned performers, selected them for roles, drew up their contracts, consented on a child’s behalf, or arranged for their attendance on set are accountable for their own decisions. Where a female manager or mother knowingly facilitated an abusive system, she must not be portrayed as a passive link in the institutional chain. Yet treating all women in a production’s cast or all families as accomplices would also destroy the concrete basis of this inquiry.
At a sales convention organized by MGM in 1937, approximately 120 young female dancers and extras attended believing they had been summoned for filming. In reality, the women had been brought in to entertain the company’s male guests. Patricia Douglas reported that an MGM employee raped her there. The ensuing events raised questions about the studio’s ability to influence complaints and public opinion. The women were directed into entertaining men under the promise of acting work; the rape allegation then became a struggle waged in the shadow of corporate authority. (🔗)
An investigation of this case must follow not only what happened to the woman who alleged rape, but also the employment pretext under which the event was organized. The actions of officials who invited the dancers, directed them to the event, and knew its real character form part of the company’s organization of the affair. If relevant documents show that a female employee knowingly participated in the deception, her responsibility must be recorded by the same material standard as that of the male executives. Imputing such complicity to anyone without identifying the person and the act, however, would once again substitute a prearranged scheme for the evidence.
The essence of the system known as the casting couch is sexual blackmail: a producer or director with authority over roles and career opportunities demands sexual intimacy from an aspiring performer. The applicant’s need for work becomes dependent on the decision-making power of the person opposite them. The patronage power of the ballet subscriber and the economic influence of the geisha customer reappear under different names at the studio door. What is sometimes demanded in exchange for entry is direct control over the performer’s body.
When a woman occupies the executive’s chair, that chair retains its power to provide employment. In a case where a female casting director or manager knowingly mediates sexual coercion, reducing her responsibility on the grounds that it is ‘an industry in which women are victims too’ does not explain how coercion is organized at work. The inquiry must establish who conveyed the sexual demand, what employment consequence was attached to refusal, and who shut the door to a career.
Over the course of Rita Hayworth’s career, the studio remade her name, hair, appearance, and public persona. Biographical testimony from the period also recounts sexual demands and pressure directed at Hayworth by studio executive Harry Cohn. The woman exalted onscreen as the Love Goddess could encounter pressure from studio authority in her actual working life. The company that produced the woman’s image was the same company that controlled her career.
In South Korea, 성상납 (seongsangnap) is the term for a system of providing sexual services to influential people. Investigations concerning actress 장자연 (Jang Ja-yeon) brought forward allegations involving demands for sexual services between her management company and powerful men. In India, the Hema Committee report released in 2024 recorded that demands made of female performers in exchange for roles were expressed in veiled words such as adjustment and compromise. Sexual demands and unequal power relations could lie beneath these words that had entered the language of career bargaining.
In France, the authority of the auteur director, celebrated as creative genius, was tested by allegations of sexual and professional domination over young actors. Judith Godrèche’s testimony about a relationship that began when she was a child raised questions about a system in which a director could intervene simultaneously in a performer’s career and private life. Creative authority does not grant immunity from allegations of sexual abuse when a child performer stands opposite an adult director.
In Last Tango in Paris, Maria Schneider recounted being humiliated by a detail of a scene that had not been disclosed to her beforehand; the decision was linked to the director’s desire to elicit a genuine emotional reaction from the actress. The performers in La Vie d’Adèle also testified about the filming of lengthy and demanding sexual scenes. The director’s artistic goal, the performer’s privacy, and power relations on set came into conflict in these examples. A performer’s body is not filming material that can be used without limits to produce the emotional effect a director wants.
The issue becomes graver when a child actor is involved, because adults often make the career decisions. Brooke Shields’s mother, Teri Shields, permitted nude photographs of her daughter to be taken when she was ten years old. Shields later appeared in Pretty Baby, playing a child forced into prostitution. Court records concerning the photographic work state that her mother signed the consent form and that $450 was paid to the child performer for the photo sessions. Sexualized images of a child’s body entered circulation through family approval and commercial contracts. When discussing the production of images of children that can be marketed to a pedophilic gaze, the documents signed and decisions made by adults must also be scrutinized. (🔗)
In the case of Teri Shields, the woman’s action shown in the document is direct and concrete: the mother signed the consent form. That signature is part of an adult decision concerning commerce in the child’s image; the assumption that ‘her mother wanted what was best for her’ cannot erase the decision from history. The payment for the photo sessions and the child’s age are also on record. Any further conclusion that the mother had pedophilic intent or participated in a particular crime requires separate evidence. For a forceful critique, the documented signature and the commercial circulation of the image are important enough in themselves.
In this case, sexualized images of a real child were placed on the market through legal and commercial decisions made by adults. A director’s prestige, the story of a successful child star, and the film’s place in art history cannot invalidate the court record documenting who authorized what. The possibility of selling a child’s image to adult customers and viewers is a concrete dimension of the discussion of pedophilia that cannot be silenced by aesthetic prestige.
The question here is this: Why and how could an adult’s signature substitute for a child’s consent? Who calculated the image’s value, who approved the contract, and what did the company gain? When the mother stands at the center of the adult decision, assigning all responsibility to the director or the male viewer alone silences half of what the document says. Every document signed on behalf of a child is an examinable act of the adult who signed it.
The mother of the ballet student, the proprietress of the geisha house, the mummy intermediary of the dance hall, and the child actor’s manager worked in different worlds. Their shared mechanism was the combination of authority to protect or train with material gain. A woman who knowingly prepares a child for sexual exploitation, directs the child to a customer, or profits from the child’s employment is not a compassionate observer outside the system of exploitation, but the perpetrator of her own act. The same applies to a male operator, father, customer, or executive. When authority over a child becomes a means of making exploitation possible, words such as family, art, and profession serve to manufacture excuses.
Edward Said’s Küçük Hanım Error: Turning a Real Courtesan into Scenery for Theory
Edward Said’s example of Küçük Hanım in Orientalism is sufficiently revealing to test the strength of the critique of Orientalism against concrete history. The issue here is not simply a difference of theoretical opinion; it is how the origins, location, words, and prostitution milieu of a real woman were reshaped within a theoretical narrative.
Gustave Flaubert met the dancer and courtesan Küçük Hanım during his journey through Egypt in 1850. Said turned this encounter into a symbol of the Western man’s speaking on behalf of an Eastern woman. What became decisive was less the real woman’s life than her representation by a Western narrator.
Said made the following categorical statement about the woman:
“she never spoke of herself” (🔗)
Yet Jennifer Yee, comparing Flaubert’s original travel records with Said’s account, identifies direct historical discrepancies in the example on which the theory rests.
According to Flaubert’s notes, Küçük Hanım was originally from Damascus; Said describes her as Egyptian. Flaubert met her in Esna; Said relocates the meeting to Wadi Halfa, approximately five hundred kilometers farther south. The woman’s identity and the geography of the event were distorted in the process of turning them into a theoretical example.
Moreover, the Küçük Hanım of Flaubert’s records is not a silent figure. She speaks, gives orders to her employees, jokes with her guards, communicates with visitors, and exercises authority over relationships in her own workplace. These are authentic historical details about the woman; they do not deserve to be treated as footnotes to a theoretical image of womanhood.
Küçük Hanım’s giving orders and managing relationships at her workplace is not enough to declare her automatically a perpetrator of exploitation; it is, however, genuine information about her power and actions that must not be erased from history. Describing her only as a passive woman represented by a Western man eliminates what she said to her employees and how she conducted her own business. Investigating the woman’s actual power disrupts two separate simplifications that make her either a romantic victim or an untouchable object of representation.
In Said’s account, however, this woman who speaks, issues orders, and conducts working relationships is reduced to a symbol of the Eastern woman silenced by a Western man. The claim made about the woman’s voice conflicts with her actual speech in the documents.
Jennifer Yee’s conclusion is therefore severe: turning the real Küçük Hanım into a figure representing the entirety of the East leads postcolonial criticism to reproduce within its own text the generalizing operation it targets. The woman becomes a symbol made to carry the claims of two different narratives about an entire geographical region. (🔗)
Said’s errors about origins and location are not minor details. When a woman’s connection to Damascus becomes Egyptian identity and her meeting in Esna is moved to Wadi Halfa, a new theoretical map is constructed over the documents. And when her speech, authority at work, and everyday activities are pushed into the background, the real person is effectively silenced in the historical narrative even as she is declared to have been silenced.
Furthermore, Küçük Hanım was not an abstract Eastern woman but a real courtesan who danced and received customers. She had relationships with employees and visitors; she operated in a concrete sector of the prostitution market. Studying her life raises questions about customers, money, services, labor, and mediation. In Said’s account, the emphasis falls on Flaubert’s power to represent the woman. When debate over representation replaces the material history of the establishment, the actual organization of the prostitution market remains in darkness.
In this example, the founding gesture of the critique of Orientalism suffers a bitter reversal: the woman said to have been silenced by a Western text is severed from her own words and economic activities in the critical reading as well. To ignore a woman’s actual voice while declaring on her behalf that the entire East has been silenced is to exercise the very power of representation being criticized once again.
The Orientalist Fairy Tale That Purges Geisha Culture of Prostitution: Who Exonerates the Female Proprietress?
Kimiko Akita’s 2006 article Orientalism and the Binary of Fact and Fiction in Memoirs of a Geisha clearly demonstrates how a defense of cultural respectability can conflict with historical records. The central question is not just whether Hollywood eroticized the geisha, but also which words are used to recount Japanese geisha establishments’ own history of prostitution, debt, and child labor.
Akita makes the following generalization:
“The Japanese have always understood geisha apart from prostitution.”
Akita then presents geisha work as a highly respected profession and a living cultural treasure. She criticizes Hollywood’s sexualized representation of the geisha as a distortion of Japanese culture. Yet this absolute separation collapses once the prostitution, customer, and operator relationships described in Japanese historical records are taken into account. A claim to defend a culture can become an effort to clear the record of exploitation within that culture. (🔗)
Japanese sources record that some historical branches of geisha work developed out of the private prostitution market, that urban geishas sold sexual services during particular periods, that girls were handed over to establishments at very young ages, and that their earnings were shared under debt-bound service contracts. The occupational history described in these sources is one in which art and prostitution were sometimes organized together within the same establishment.
In the face of these documents, Akita’s word always is indefensible. It is an absolute assertion that erases historical variation in a single stroke. The fact that geisha work was practiced as high art in certain circles is one thing; proclaiming that its entire history was a profession separate from prostitution is another.
The problem is not merely a mistaken generalization. While the Western author’s transformation of the geisha into an erotic figure is criticized, actual prostitution, debt-bound labor, and the subjection of children to adult economic decisions in Japanese entertainment establishments are pushed behind a narrative of respectable culture. The objection to Western eroticization acquires a historically exculpatory function the moment it renders the concrete acts of local customers and operators invisible.
Another important figure rendered invisible by this categorical defense is the female operator of the geisha house. When Japanese historical records describe prostitution and the sharing of earnings with an operator, the picture no longer consists solely of a male spectator outside and a female artist inside; a third party arranging the business also appears. If that operator is a woman, her powers of accounting and supervision cannot be sacrificed for the sake of Japanese culture’s claim to respectability. A cultural defense that erases the female proprietress’s commercial role can exonerate the female manager of local exploitation.
The experience of an elite geisha such as 岩崎峰子 (Iwasaki Mineko) is, of course, a genuine part of history. But her career cannot represent the past of all geisha establishments in Japan. The testimony of Masuda Sayo, who describes being sold as a child, shows that very different arrangements of earnings and obligation could exist under the umbrella of the same profession. The prestigious artist’s life cannot cover up the poor child’s life of debt-bound service.
The distance between these two women’s testimonies must be preserved in particular: Mineko describes her own professional experience, while Masuda Sayo describes the consequences of being sold as a child. The prestigious artist’s ability to speak does not authorize her to speak for the indebted child. Likewise, responsibility for female proprietresses’ actions concerning customers, earnings, and discipline cannot be dispersed among the successes of other geishas. Women’s history is not the history of one undifferentiated womanhood; it is also the history of the power women exercised over one another.
Joan E. Ericson’s Con/texts for Viewing Geisha makes the distinction between these two experiences visible. Evidence of sexual services, child labor, and economic dependence associated with geisha work can thus be found within the very sources used in debates surrounding Orientalism.
Akita’s categorical defense directly conflicts with these records. Calling geisha culture an art is not a license to erase from history prostitution conducted under the geisha name, child labor, and debt-bound employment.
The Second Act of the Critics of Orientalism: Making the Text Speak Instead of Prostitution, Representation Instead of the Child
The substitution seen in Said’s Küçük Hanım example continues in some subsequent critiques dealing with texts, photographs, and harems. In each study, the question must be asked anew: While investigating how a woman is represented, can we also see whom she actually worked for, from whom she received money, and under whose authority she lived?
Rana Kabbani turned Flaubert’s encounter with a courtesan into an example of Europe’s sexual fantasy about the East. The woman’s dance became a symbol of an entire geographical expanse. Yet concrete history also includes the customer relationships, workplace duties, and everyday life of the woman who performed that dance. Turning a real courtesan into an inter-civilizational fantasy is not sufficient to recount the material records of the prostitution market in which she worked.
A detail such as Küçük Hanım’s giving orders to her own employees is enough to change the way this literature operates: the woman is not solely the object of a representation imposed upon her, but a historical person who established working relationships with others. When the real authority exercised by one woman and the pressures suffered by other women are compressed into the same marker of sex, the distinction between employer and worker disappears.
Lisa Lowe examined sexuality, capitalism, and representation in Flaubert’s female figures. But decoding metaphors of capitalist exploitation in literature is no substitute for researching actual money, labor, customer networks, and intermediaries in a courtesan establishment. The image of exploitation in the text and the operation of exploitation in the workplace must each be recorded separately.
Malek Alloula’s Le Harem colonial examines how Algerian women were pictured in French colonial postcards. Some of the models were women engaged in prostitution. Gregory Betts criticized the relegation of prostitution’s structural relationships to the background in this reading. Alongside analyzing the colonial gaze of the photograph, it is necessary to establish which customers the photographed woman worked with, under what conditions, and through which commercial intermediaries. The woman represented on the postcard also belonged to a real world of work and prostitution.
In Meyda Yeğenoğlu’s Colonial Fantasies, the question of oppression experienced by local women within their own societies is discussed through the position of the Western interlocutor. This choice can become particularly problematic in concrete cases of child exploitation. The act of an adult who directs a child into sexual abuse does not change according to who investigates that act or from which geographical location. What happened to the girl, who did it, and who profited must be recorded.
For this reason, criticism of the ‘Western gaze’ cannot stand in for investigation of the concrete decisions of a local female operator. The mother handing the child over to the establishment may be local; the proprietress may be a bearer of artistic tradition; the female intermediary may belong to the same community. None of these circumstances in itself justifies the acts of selecting customers, collecting debts, or employing a child. The identity of the person vested with authority and how it was used must be documented.
Reina Lewis’s work on the personal accounts of women in Ottoman harems brings out women’s role in producing representations. Yet the experiences of elite women who left written works do not account for the full range of powers exercised over girls employed in the harem, concubines who were purchased, and female administrators. We must listen to whoever spoke in the harem; but who bought, employed, supervised, and punished whom is also part of the same historical accounting.
Reducing harem history to what elite women said about their own lives does not explain what happened to girls and female attendants on the lower rungs of the hierarchy. In concrete cases where a female harem administrator possessed powers to issue orders, impose discipline, or allocate resources, that power must be described in its own name. Writing as if all women in the harem possessed the same authority also buries the rulers and the ruled in the same category.
Chandra Talpade Mohanty’s objection to narratives that reduce women to a single victim figure also requires distinguishing between women within a system of exploitation. The position of the girl driven into prostitution is not the same as that of the adult woman who sends her to the establishment. The female proprietress’s authority over income and her decisions concerning the child are material indications of that difference. Language that erases unequal power among women also erases the adult intermediary standing opposite the child.
The sentence ‘women are one hundred percent accomplices’ can collapse these distinctions instead of explaining them: the girl sold as a child and the woman who knowingly sells her, or the actor subjected to sexual coercion and the executive who facilitates it, do not participate in the same act. An adult woman who knowingly participates bears full responsibility; declaring everyone guilty simply for being a woman, however, obscures who actually committed which act. Strong criticism of generalizations that shield female perpetrators consists not in accusing women collectively, but in setting out each female perpetrator’s contract, order, collection of money, and decision, one by one.
The work of Jennifer Yee, Barkahoum Ferhati, Gregory Betts, Uttara Asha Coorlawala, and Davesh Soneji provides concrete material for comparing representation with historical labor arrangements. Yee examines the real person of Küçük Hanım, Ferhati the prostitution market, and Soneji the material lives of devadasi communities. These studies help make visible once again the contracts, employment status, customer networks, and economic dependence behind the aesthetic image.
The gravest historical weakness of the critique of Orientalism emerges where the concrete lives of women and children can be reduced to material for a grand debate about representation. While pages are written about the text’s viewpoint, the owner of the prostitution establishment, the money paid by the customer, the contract made in childhood, and the perpetrator of abuse may all be left in darkness.
The Image’s Second Market: Painting, Colonial Photography, Anime, and Cosmetics
Once the woman or child onstage becomes an image, that image can be detached from the artist’s actual working life and resold for years. The image’s long lifespan also transforms the memory of the labor system that produced it.
Edgar Degas’s ballerinas brought the bodies of little girls at the Paris Opéra into the enduring figures of modern painting and sculpture. Colonial postcards marketed the jewelry, costumes, and poses of Algerian dancers to tourists. Japanese geisha photographs and European Japonisme, meanwhile, produced a new template of beauty around kimono, hair, faces, and refinement. The ballerina’s working conditions and the painter’s artwork, the dancer’s customer and the photographer’s postcard revenue, began to exist in separate markets.
The family’s decision reappears in the gulf between selling an image as beauty and the working conditions of the child’s body that produced it. As the painter or photographer creates the image, the adult who brought the child performer there, authorized the child’s work, or received payment must also be investigated according to the case. When a female relative or manager made that decision, the real transaction behind the image is attributable to her as well. The transformation of the image into an artwork cannot erase adult mediation from the past.
Cinema expanded this circulation. Cartoons, anime, advertising, and the cosmetics industry opened additional markets in images that reshape the female face. Anime eyes, eyelid surgery, and the fox-eye trend show how the face is redesigned through drawing, cosmetic surgery, and digital imaging techniques. Once a face becomes an aesthetic model, it can be detached from the historical performer’s body and labor and attached to new commercial relationships.
The details of this cosmetic and visual transformation are examined in the article Why Are Anime Eyes So Big? Cosmetic Butchery First Made Slanted Eyes Seem Strange and Then Turned Them into an Ideal. The central distinction here is between the historical performer’s actual working conditions and the commercial beauty template derived from her appearance. (🔗)
The image of a child, dancer, or actor may outlive the institution that trained them. Painting, film, and digital images can preserve a single moment of a body and convert it into money repeatedly. A profound rupture thus arises between the real life of a performer who once lived in economic dependence and the figure of flawless beauty purchased by later spectators. The image may continue to shine while the labor system that produced it becomes invisible.
In this second market, too, words such as ‘motherhood,’ ‘refinement,’ and ‘protection’ must not be allowed to obscure concrete contracts. The child whose body and labor were subject to decisions in the first market may become the source of an image resold in the second. It is necessary to trace who gave the initial permission, who received the money for the shoot, and which company managed its subsequent circulation. The child in the image may grow up; the history of the signatures adults placed on documents on that child’s behalf must not disappear into an enchanting fairy tale about art.
The article Cinema Is Nothing but Pornography Embedded in the Format of a Lesson in Adulthood also examines the relationship between intimacy and acting in cinema. The study titled Nuclear Pedophilic Puppeteering: The United States, Japan, and Europe Since 1945 discusses how children’s bodies are positioned under cultural prestige and adult authority. These links point to further areas in which the relationships of art and imagery to the sexualization of children demand direct scrutiny. (🔗) (🔗)
Who Paid the Price of Respectability, Who Took the Money, and Which Adult Sold the Child?
Looking across the different traditions of ballet, geisha, kabuki, Peking opera, Indian classical dance, court entertainment, and cinema, the same harsh question returns: How did the authority to train a performer turn into economic domination over that performer’s labor, body, and private life? The answer lies not in aesthetic praise, but in records of payments, contracts, customers, debts, prohibitions, permissions, and testimony.
The wealthy subscriber in Paris, the danna in Japan, the state official in Korea, the opera customer in China, the kotha patron in India, the king in Cambodia, and the Hollywood producer were powerful figures in different institutions. In certain historical environments, they derived social prestige, commercial income, or sexual privileges from performances. Authority over work and careers could become tied to demands for sexual access. Rank, money, and cultural prestige could become instruments that opened the door to access to human bodies.
The accounting cannot be directed solely at the powerful man near the stage. The family that handed over the child, the proprietress who managed the child’s labor debt, the female intermediary who arranged the customer, the palace administrator who organized rehearsals and punishments, and the manager who marketed the child’s image also made concrete decisions. The sex of an adult who organizes, facilitates, or shares in the proceeds of a child’s being driven into prostitution or sexual abuse does not diminish that adult’s responsibility.
To record responsibility fully, the map of perpetrators must be drawn around real actions rather than a female–male opposition. The male customer may have made the purchase; the female proprietress may have set the terms of sale; the mother may have brought the child and collected the payment; the company may have packaged the image. Each bears an action and responsibility of their own to the extent documented. The fact that one is male and another female neither divides nor mitigates their actions. A woman who knowingly participates in child exploitation is fully complicit.
The sexual exploitation of children, adult prostitution, concubinage, paid dancing, the trade in sexualized images of children, and sexual coercion directed at actors are different historical acts. Cases in which these acts converge within a single institution, however, constitute the most damning records. When pedophilia and the sexual abuse of children are at issue, softening the subject with phrases such as ‘erotic tradition’ or ‘artistic upbringing’ conceals what children were subjected to.
The records that can test the critique of Orientalism are not theoretical abstractions: the prostitution record of the geisha house, the courtesan’s customer, how the girl dancer was taken from her family, to whom the opera boy was presented, who marketed the child actor’s image, and who exerted sexual pressure on the adult performer. When these records are examined, debates over cultural representation begin to answer to the lives of real people.
Said’s misrepresentation of Küçük Hanım’s origins and the place of the encounter; Akita’s insistence that geisha work has always been separate from prostitution; and the relegation of actual prostitution relationships to the background in some interpretations of colonial postcards all deliver the same historical warning. A powerful thesis about a woman’s image does not excuse inaccurate accounts of her real life or failures to investigate it fully.
Cultural respectability is not a certificate of purity that arose of its own accord. If an institution’s past includes child labor, prostitution, debt bondage, sexual blackmail, or abuse, the artistic prestige it later acquires does not change the history of those acts. That institution’s history cannot be considered complete without recording who received the money and who exercised power over whose body.
The prostitution records of the Paris Opéra; the debt-bound service relationships of Japanese geisha establishments; the children sold in the Chinese opera world; the sexual exploitation of devadasi girls; the commissions of female intermediaries in Singapore dance halls; and Hollywood’s documents concerning allegations of rape, sexual coercion, and the trade in children’s images all stand at the very center of the history of respectable culture. These are neither marginal embellishments nor inappropriate anecdotes. They are direct evidence of the conditions under which institutions celebrated as art actually operated.
The mother involved in patronage bargaining for a ballet student, the proprietress managing debt in a Japanese geisha establishment, the chief wife wielding authority over punishments and payments in a Cambodian palace, the mummy collecting commissions from customers in Singapore, the mother appropriating her twelve-year-old daughter’s earnings, and Teri Shields signing permission for photographs of a child are neither the same person nor perpetrators of the same act. They are brought together because adult women appear on the historical stage not only as bodies to be looked at, but also as parties to concrete decisions and monetary relationships. Which act amounts to child labor exploitation, which to complicity in sexual abuse, and which to a contested commercial permission or managerial domination must be determined by the evidence. This distinction does not disperse the female perpetrator’s responsibility; on the contrary, it fixes responsibility in the right place.
How the elegance of the stage, the beauty of the silver screen, and the cultural prestige of classical art were established must be explained alongside all these records. Who handed over the girl? Who presented the boy to a customer? Who ran the prostitution establishment? Who authorized the bodily intervention? Who made the actor’s job conditional on a sexual demand? Who shared the income? Which institution then called these things art, tradition, patronage, education, or cultural heritage? History’s reckoning begins the moment it confronts the spectator, entranced by the beauty of the image, with these questions. Cultural prestige can cover up exploitation; documentation brings the exploiter’s name and the exploited person’s life back into view.
The final reckoning is this: If a woman selected customers in a system of child exploitation, she selected them; if she handed over a child, she handed over a child; if she entered a debt, she entered a debt; if she collected a commission, she collected a commission. Softening these acts with words such as ‘motherhood,’ ‘female solidarity,’ ‘bearer of tradition,’ or ‘refinement’ directly distorts material history. Male demand alone does not explain the market; alongside the buyer must be recorded the person who brought the child, the person who established the business, and the person who collected the proceeds. The responsibility of an adult woman who knowingly acts against a child is one hundred percent her own responsibility.
[…] (Englisch, Türkisch) […]
LikeLike